For Democracy, Any Man Would Give His Only Begotten Son

This video inspired me to seek out the movie Johnny Got His Gun. I did, and still do, think it's an excellent movie.

I never "got" the anti-war message, maybe because when I first saw the movie, I was fairly apolitical. Or maybe I just lack nuance, not to mention layers.

It was the concept of being in that situation which captivated me. Unable to see, hear, speak, or move, yet being totally aware of what's going on around you.

At any rate, I really just decided to post this because we have incurable insomniacs around here that need some high-quality entertainment.

Posted by: Vinnie at 11:57 PM


1 Ummm.... you realize that Dalton Trumbo's Johnny Got His Gun is one of the classic anti-war books written? That is the movie they are using in their video.

Posted by: background N015e at September 01, 2006 02:56 AM

2 Did you read what I wrote under the fold?

Posted by: Vinnie at September 01, 2006 07:04 AM

3 What the left doesn't understand is that the right doesn't want war. Anybody that has been there doesn't want war. The problem is that the left doesn't want war at any cost, while the right understands war is sometimes necessary. But like you said, perhaps we're just not nuanced enough...

Posted by: Duncan Avatar at September 01, 2006 08:22 AM

4 I read the book on HS. Great book I recommend it. ER uh I'll give Vinnie that this video kicks ass.

Posted by: Darth Odie at September 01, 2006 09:05 AM

5 After seeing this video as a kid, I read the book by Trumbo, and was really struck by it. I also watched the movie. That was probably grade 7 or 8. Too much too young, maybe. It always stuck with me.

While I do think it is a great book, and a great movie, I think that the anti-war crowd are the ones not quite nuanced enough. While this work does point out the absolute horrors of war, and how a person can be dead while alive as a result of war, I don't remember it ever nuancing things enough to address issues worth fighting for. As you can see in the video, the father says, "For democracy, any man would give his only begotten son." I see two things here - 1) the term "democracy" isn't nuanced at all. I believe the war referenced in the book (it has been a while) was WW1. There is much more to the causes and purposes of WW1 than "democracy." While that line is powerful and emotionally charged, it does not communicate the full extent of why we go to war. 2) That line links war/democracy with Christian religion. The "only begotten son," bit is lifted straight from Abraham's sacrifice of Isaac, and Christ's death on the cross. While the book/film probably uses this for emotional effect, or, possibly (like I said, its been a while) to link war with religion (in America anyway), the effect is a very un-nuanced vision of what war is. It portrays people as unthinking sheep who go to war for a simple ideal. But there is much more to war than just that. Also, if I remember correctly, in the book the soldier is linked with Christ in a figurative way, so that he is seen as the vision of things to come for soldiers on the battlefield.

Finally, and this is getting too long, you have to reamamber that Trombu's book was written in 1939, in the midst of WW2, and the movie was produced in 1971, in the midst of Vietnam. So, there is bound to be echos of angst, especially in the film, about a war that was unpopular.


Posted by: Casey at September 01, 2006 11:00 AM

6 The only wars that the lefturds have ever opposed are those on behalf of liberty. They never have had a problem with violence conducted on behalf of totalitarian dictatorships.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at September 01, 2006 11:19 AM

7 IM... you will be surprised to know that even some Quakers supported attacking Afghanistan. Where you and the majority of America part company is at the right hand turn into Iraq.

Posted by: background N015e at September 01, 2006 05:56 PM

8 Vinnie,
I missed the under the fold comment... as Casey points out the time of the book and movie were relevant. What is interesting is the book briefly was a hit and then disappeared after Pearl Harbor. Trumbo, a Communist, was blacklisted in the McCarthy era and didn't really enjoy much support outside of the radical circles he traveled in. However, as Casey points out, the resurgence of the book (1967) followed by the movie (1971) was due to the hugely unpopular Vietnam war. Especially following 68 with the lifting of student deferments. I am not surprised to see it reprised now as we close in on 3,000 dead and over 20,000 wounded with an Army and Marine Corps stretched thin and backdoor drafts foreshadowing a return to some form of national compulsory service (which I would not necessarily oppose).

"I am not haunted by the fear that my brother will be sent to war. I believe there are beliefs and causes worth taking risks for, worth fighting and dying for. Rather, I am haunted by the fear that he will be sent to war thoughtlessly, carelessly... The ghost of Vietnam stares at me from a black granite wall that scars the Mall in Washington, and I am haunted by a fear of watching history repeat itself."
-- Cara Cannon Byington (1/15/03)

Posted by: background N015e at September 01, 2006 06:13 PM

9 "There is much more to the causes and purposes of WW1 than "democracy." While that line is powerful and emotionally charged, it does not communicate the full extent of why we go to war."

I think they'tr addressing war propaganda. Not the actual causes of war.

Posted by: actus at September 02, 2006 09:48 AM

10 Noise, I know you'll never be able to understand, since the study of warfare relies solely on logic and none at all on feelings, but Iraq has flushed out the jihadis and forced them to take action, which exposes them. This is the age of low-intensity warfare, and it's just not possible for wars to be as quick and neat as they once were, though they are certainly now much less bloody. The enemy has to be forced to come out and fight, and when he does, he loses. I know you can't stand the thought, but we will win, regardless of how bad the lefturds want us to lose.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at September 02, 2006 04:26 PM

11 Johnny Got His Gun was a decent book, regardless if it was anti-war. And this song (and its album) was alright, even if it marked the end of Metallica.

Posted by: Venom at September 04, 2006 09:17 AM

12 card credit offer opt [url=]card credit offer opt[/url]

Posted by: miqxv] at January 25, 2007 09:35 PM

13 antique early furniture oak [url=]antique early furniture oak[/url] antique furniture columbus ohio [url=]antique furniture columbus ohio[/url]

Posted by: cwhxy] at January 27, 2007 03:47 PM

14 sexy russian woman pic [url=]sexy russian woman pic[/url]

Posted by: hmesf] at January 27, 2007 09:04 PM

15 online fleet low interest rate credit card offer [url=]online fleet low interest rate credit card offer[/url]

Posted by: ybfcd] at January 28, 2007 05:37 AM

16 39 ashley furniture home s store [url=]39 ashley furniture home s store[/url] ashley furniture showroom [url=]ashley furniture showroom[/url]

Posted by: pntcj] at January 28, 2007 03:19 PM

17 sexy russian lesbian [url=]sexy russian lesbian[/url]

Posted by: guohl] at January 28, 2007 11:38 PM

18 russian nude photography [url=]russian nude photography[/url] russian girl wife [url=]russian girl wife[/url]

Posted by: gnsaz] at January 31, 2007 09:56 AM

19 card credit free interest offer [url=]card credit free interest offer[/url]

Posted by: tfhqq] at February 02, 2007 12:31 AM

20 ambien effects [url=]ambien effects[/url] buy ambien cr online [url=]buy ambien cr online[/url]

Posted by: sflru] at February 04, 2007 06:12 PM

21 airline purchase ticket [url=]airline purchase ticket[/url] airline cost low ticket [url=]airline cost low ticket[/url]

Posted by: qwzob] at February 05, 2007 02:22 AM

22 budget auto cheap insurance [url=]budget auto cheap insurance[/url]

Posted by: ykrgx] at February 06, 2007 07:10 PM

23 steve miller abracadabra wav [url=]steve miller abracadabra wav[/url]

Posted by: bmavb] at February 07, 2007 08:43 AM

24 card compare credit offer popular [url=]card compare credit offer popular[/url]

Posted by: vqcwr] at February 07, 2007 09:56 PM

25 card credit hsbc offer

Posted by: lfmsl] at February 08, 2007 03:21 AM

26 african american woman in wwii [url=]african american woman in wwii[/url] african beautiful woman [url=]african beautiful woman[/url] african american woman with diaes [url=]african american woman with diaes[/url]

Posted by: meqjv at May 04, 2007 04:41 AM

27 african american college scholarship woman [url=]african american college scholarship woman[/url] sexy african american woman [url=]sexy african american woman[/url] grants african american woman [url=]grants african american woman[/url]

Posted by: lcagc at May 15, 2007 06:43 PM

28 buy link tramadol [url=]buy link tramadol[/url] cheap tramadol buy online [url=]cheap tramadol buy online[/url] tramadol buy on line [url=]tramadol buy on line[/url]

Posted by: cprjw at May 21, 2007 06:48 PM

29 buy discount viagra online [url=]buy discount viagra online[/url] buy viagra online [url=]buy viagra online[/url] buy viagra without prescription [url=]buy viagra without prescription[/url]

Posted by: gkjsx at June 18, 2007 07:54 PM

30 buy discount tramadol [url=]buy discount tramadol[/url] what does tramadol hcl have in it [url=]what does tramadol hcl have in it[/url] what else besides tramadol is for pain [url=]what else besides tramadol is for pain[/url]

Posted by: hpfgi at June 22, 2007 06:12 PM

31 buy discount tramadol [url=]buy discount tramadol[/url] buy information tramadol [url=]buy information tramadol[/url] tramadol buy [url=]tramadol buy[/url]

Posted by: uttac at June 23, 2007 06:29 PM

32 buy generic viagra [url=]buy generic viagra[/url] buy discount online viagra [url=]buy discount online viagra[/url] buy viagra toronto [url=]buy viagra toronto[/url]

Posted by: mcvzq at June 28, 2007 02:29 AM

33 jessica simpson naked
hardcore video
extreme sex
granny sex
extreme anal sex
voyeur porn
amateur sex video
teen underwear
free hardcore porn
xxx chat
lindsay lohan naked
ebony porn
sex for couple
fat porn
amateur sex
celebrity porn
sex photo
young black pussy
mature dating

Posted by: xxx porn at July 03, 2007 02:23 AM

34 indian pussy
nude beach
asian teen
paris hilton sex tape
gay sex
indian sex
free porn movie
nude teen
fat pussy
free dating site

Posted by: Jungle at July 08, 2007 11:06 AM

Processing 0.0, elapsed 0.0081 seconds.
15 queries taking 0.0042 seconds, 42 records returned.
Page size 23 kb.
Powered by Minx 0.7 alpha.