1 So if I go down to Texas and git me a second wife, it woun't really be valid but I can still have me a honeymoon night?

2

So...what part of the Constitution claims to give the federal and state governments the authority to 'legalize' marriage and define "domestic unions"?

 

 

3 So...what part of the Constitution

Hello!

4 "Did Texas Ban Marriage?" asks someone identical or similar to Gabriel Malor on a blog identical or similar to Ace of Spades HQ.

5 I think it's great that they banned marriage. Government should get out of the marriage business altogether. I don't want government distributing Holy Communion any more than I want them granting Holy Matrimony.

6

stupid political stunt by Radnofsky.  This claim was all across the state in 2005 and was debunked then - it was just a scare tactic to try and keep voters from passing the thing.  It's just a scare tactic now. 

Since the first part of the act clearly recognizes marriage between a man and a woman, the second part can only apply to any other  legal status.   It's a simple matter of statutory construction, which is why this has been in the constitution for 4 years now and no one has successfully challenged it.   Radnofsky is claiming she just realized this - BS!!!!  Like I said, I saw all these claims all over Texas 4 years ago.  They were nonsense then, and they're nonsense now.

7 One of the down sides of this otherwise great place to live.  These dingbat Texas voters pass damn near every constitutional amendment no matter how awful or poorly worded.

8 So... what part of the Constitutional requires Warren Bonesteel to be a douchebag?

9 So, yes, Texas banned marriage.

No, they didn't. Marriage isn't identical or similar to marriage. It is Marriage.
In the same sentence replace the word water for marriage.
Does it follow Texas banned water?

10 Beh. Always a stupid typo.

Still, Bonesteel's a douchbag. Any minute he'll launch into a rant about how we're no different than the lefties, he's the only truly principled person IN THE WORLD!!!!, blah, blah, blah.

11 Marriage isn't identical or similar to marriage. It is Marriage.

Rocks, marriage isn't identical to marriage?  Really?

12 Texans can sweat over whether any liberal judges will temporarily adopt a strictly textualist jurisprudence to cause trouble

Not that any liberals would intentionally throw the entire system in disarray to make a point.  Nah.  Never.

13 This will provide the basis for innumerable future sitcom plots.

14 Strict Interpretation.  I don't care about the intent of legislature or absurd results.  We're a nation of laws, not men.


"now Texans can sweat over whether any liberal judges will temporarily adopt a strictly textualist jurisprudence to cause trouble."

This is intriguing.  Are you implying that textualism isn't the only proper method of statutory interpretation?  Stating that it "cause[s] trouble" is pretty bold; the implication there is that this method in this case would be wrong and that we should suddenly start gazing at intent and leg history and what not. 

I'd be very interested to hear about your judicial philosophy.  Seems like you just embraced the formalist critique (i.e. that it's all judicial action, whether you wrap yourself in the text or consider other factors).

15 Rocks, marriage isn't identical to marriage?  Really?

Posted by: Gabriel Malor at November 19, 2009 09:46 AM (Mi2wf)

Yes, really. How can something be identical to itself? Are you identical to Gabriel Malor? Or are you Gabriel Malor? You can't be both.

16 Rocks, marriage isn't identical to marriage?  Really?

The property of identity is not the same as being identical. If you have two identical books, you still have two of them. You cannot declare that, since they're identical, there is only one of them.

17 What are the implications for divorce then?

18 What are the implications for divorce then?

None, because Gabriel's talking out his ass.

19 It's just a constitution. Who cares about the actual words? Just give me everything I want and we're cool.

20 Part A:  The people through their constitution establish and define marriage.
Part B:  The legislature and the subdivision of the state can't change that or establish something similar.

21

The only way you could have avoided this mess is to do away with attorneys because its going to happen somehow even if there remained only one attorney in the entire world.

We are still intepreting what the plain text of the US Constitution says after 222 years so what do you expect.  

22 "..I doubt even the most conservative judge would fail to read the second part of the amendment.."

I hope your right.

23 "This state or a political subdivision of this state may not create or recognize any legal status identical or similar to marriage."


depends on what the meaning of "is" is....

24 This whole situation is quite the conundrum for me...

I support the rights of gays to marry, but I abhor the moral pretense, deceit and contempt displayed by those who are pushing this right.

25 "We are still intepreting what the plain text of the US Constitution says after 222 years so what do you expect."

We're still interpreting what the "plain text" of the Bible says 1700 years later, too, and it's not lawyers driving it.  Context matters, and neither ancient Israel nor colonial America are the same context as America today.  An awful lot is presumed by the Constitution, both in terms of what's normal and in terms of what the reader should already know.

26 No it doesn't.  IDENTICAL means just like something that ALREADY EXISTS.  You can't have an IDENTICAL item without having the ORIGINAL.  All that the text states is that you can't create MORE types of marriage (that are IDENTICAL or SIMILAR).  

It says nothing about the original whatsoever.

27 People's Front of Judea gets an "A" for reading comprehension.  Unfortunately, there's a whole passel of lawyers that won't.

28 I'm still waiting for Texas to outlaw liberals.

29
Marriage is for SPLITTERS!

30

We're still interpreting what the "plain text" of the Bible says 1700 years later, too

Talk about not being identical or even similar.

31 if true, Divorce Atty,s  will go broke.

32 if true, Divorce Atty,s  will go broke.

You say that like it is a bad thing.

33 Rickshaw, imagine the wailing and gnashing of toofers.

34 So...what part of the Constitution claims to give the federal and state governments the authority to 'legalize' marriage and define "domestic unions"?

Typical liberal thought process.

Hey DA; the Constituion doesn't give the States a damn thing. It is the other way around. Why don't you at least try to get an education before you make a fool out of yourself.

35 Define irony:

For the liberals judges to make light of this reading of the law, they would have to read it literally.  Not a "living document", like everything else is.

Now if we can get them to treat the Constitution the same way.

36 Marriage? Never heard of it.

37 Texas didn't ban marriage. A place identical to Texas banned marriage.

38 No, DIVORCE is for SPLITTERS!!!

39 Leave it to a lawyer to find a loophole.  Then they wonder why they often rate no. 1 on most hated professional careers lists.

40 Identical is identical to the word identical.

41 If gay marriage is outlawed, only gay outlaws will get married.

42

If I said, "You cannot create a recipe identical to Oreo's" that doesn't make it so Oreo can't make their own cookies.  So, nope, Texas did not outlaw marriage; it outlawed anything attempting to be like marriage.

Also, Warren asks: "So...what part of the Constitution claims to give the federal and state governments the authority to 'legalize' marriage and define 'domestic unions'?"

Answer: None for the federal, but for the state governments: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."  That's the 10th Amendment.  So yes, states have the Constitutional right to define marriage for their states.

43 Fuck you fucking fuckers

44 Ummmm, yeah it would take a very liberal or extremely pro-gay (yeah I know, same thing) reading of the second part to think it outlaws marriage.  Meanwhile, back in the real world, which as much as I don't like Texas I must admit it's increasingly our last redoubt of reality, gays can scream all they want, real marriage is legal.

45

 So...no one has a constitutional argumement to support the feds and states rights to interfere in your personal lives? (Logical fallacies don't count.)

46 So...no one has a constitutional argumement to support the feds and states rights to interfere in your personal lives? (Logical fallacies don't count.)

You are not really that dumb are you?

47

Standard contract template:

Section 1 - "Marriage" is defined

Section 2 - "Marriage" is referenced

That DA candidate may be a hell of an attorney in her legal specialty, but I'd guess that specialty isn't contract law.

48

Sounds like a common object-oriented programming bug.

You can instantiate two objects which are identical in all their properties and methods. But if you compare the two, they come up different. That's because they are, after all, two separate objects.

Generally programmers will separate out their comparison for whether they are looking twice at the same duck, from that for whether they are looking at two objects which look and quack like ducks.

Texas designed its code for "identical to" which is a test for the second. The problem is that marriage itself is also identical to marriage. They should have coded also for a check on whether the incoming test case was marriage, and discounted that case.

49

Answer: None for the federal, but for the state governments: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."  That's the 10th Amendment.  So yes, states have the Constitutional right to define marriage for their states.

And, by extension, it's legitimate for the federal government to say no state is required to recognize the non-marriages created by other states.

50 You are not really that dumb are you?

Yes, he is.

51 So...what part of the Constitution

Hey - don't forget about me!

52

 So...no one has a constitutional argumement to support the feds and states rights to interfere in your personal lives? (Logical fallacies don't count.)

Bonerhead, the government is not interfering AT ALL in your personal life. What is happening is it is refusing -- due to the peacefully expressed desires of the vast majority of voters -- to extend a particular form of contract to cover cases it has never in history covered.

Shack up with your boyfriend, girlfriend, gang, or pets and declare yourselves to be "married" -- unless one of them is incapable of consenting, the government won't give a rat's ass. But you won't get the government seal of approval for it, either.

53 everyone's already pointed it out:

No, they didn't. Marriage isn't identical or similar to marriage. It is Marriage.

I think everyone's pretty much pointed out the flaw in the argument.   

"Identical" cannot be defined as the object that it's being compared to.  The definition of the word all but makes this argument this Dumbocrat moot.

54 Come on, any reading like that is moronic.  It does not say that marriage is banned, but legal statuses similar to or identical to marriage.  Let's be a little more intelligent.

55

I didn't say the "marriage is illegal" reading was smart. I just said the reading was programmatically correct.

You can swear at your computer all you like, but if you write shitty code, you'll get shitty results. Likewise, you can curse lawyers and liberals all you like... but if you write the law in the wrong way, then you're going to get problems.

56 Because Democrat judges are such sticklers for the letter of the law...

Right?

57 Bender, you're not the first to be pwned by a hacker who cannot, himself, code worth a damn.

58

Anyway, just so y'all know where I stand: I'm a Texan who thinks "homosexual marriage" is a contradiction in terms. I don't think homosexual unions deserve the same rights as the norm.

But my *facepalm*ing here is directed at the idiot who wrote this poorly-worded law. FAIL, one might say.

59 Commenters are reading an implicit "other" in subpart B ("The state shall not recognize other legal statuses"), because they know the intent of the amendment. The point of my original post is that the text alone does not get you there.

Yes, it does. Identical and similar are descriptions of comparisons. Comparison requires more than one of something. You can not compare something to itself.
The one thing this clause doesn't ban is marriage because marriage is necessary to make the comparison, and the clause, work.

Forget the word marriage. Let's say the clause read like this instead.

"This state or a political subdivision of this state may not create or recognize any number identical or similar to 1."

If someone were suggesting that the number 2 represents a single object and was banned from doing that with this clause only a fool would suggest you have also banned the number 1. You can not prove 2 is not identical or similar to 1 unless 1 preexists your comparison. The comparison, and the clause, would totally break down without it.

60 And this is why most lawyers should be placed in burlap sacks and beaten with reeds.

For christ's sake, write the law as plainly and unambiguously as possible
so there can be no doubt as to what you are allowing and what you are
disallowing.

61 Yeah, I don't get it either. Plain reading does not exclude marriage simply because if it did, then you could not read the statute because it would use something that does not exist as a definition.

You can play logic parlor games all you want but it says what it is supposed to say. This is why I say that it is a lawyre's job to cause problems, not to solve them.

62 Every part has to be given meaning.  If it banned marriage, then "identical to" would have no meaning.

63 Much ado about nothing. It's no more than an eventual loser trying to fan some life into the campaign.

Texas has plenty of case law on plain meaning and legislative intent. There is no way this goes anywhere.

64

"In Pari Materia: Upon the same subject matter or subject.

The in pari materia canon requires that statutory language be construed in the context of the whole act and that all statutes concerning the same subject matter be read together and, if possible, harmonized to avoid repeal by implication.⁵⁴ The term in pari materia signals a transition from a focus on the specific language at issue to an analysis of that language in the larger context of other statutes or language."

65

 Fortunately, I doubt even the most conservative judge would fail to read the second part of the amendment in light of the first part,

Refer to the 2nd Amendment of the Constitution and then would you want to place a bet?

66

Marriages, in times past, particularly when the Constitution was written, were conducted and recorded by religious leaders in churches. At that time, statist legalization and control of marriage wasn't a part of the 'programming.' It wasn't a part of the intent of the Founding Fathers and of those who designed our founding documents. It was unthinkable to such men and women.

Today, the government requires that all persons who perform a marriage ceremony be certified and registered by the government. Individuals who wish to become married must also register with the government, and in many states, be 'certified' in order to become married. The government must be paid for licenses, fees and certifications at every step of the process. Hundreds and even thousands of laws at the local, state and federal levels now determine who can become married and what penalties or advantages can be imposed on marriage or upon those whose private lives are not 'acceptable' to others. (in this matter, those who promote legalized gay marriages are no less guilty than those opposed to such 'unions.')

Where is the personal freedom in this institution when the government is so heavily involved?? Where is the right to privacy? The pursuit of happiness? Freedom of religion - or the right to be free from statist religious laws in such public affairs?

So...where's all of that small government conservatism, now? Where is the fiscal conservatism? Where are those who love freedom and who claim to support and defend the Constitution?

Logical fallacies offered in response to my queries are not addressing the bottom line nor are they questioning all of those decades of statist propaganda and indoctrination that has been the bane of your eXistenZ and which most of you claim to despise? Yet, you continue to parrot that propaganda and indocrination at every turn???

If the Texas law is defined as banning the legal instution of marriage, they will not only have restored a plain and simple reading of The US Constituion, but a a plain and simple reading of its own state constitution.

Ontology, history, English common law, upon which our own Constitution and other freedom documents are based, even the plain and simple meanings of commonly used words, rules against any other interpretation than what I have offered here.

 Government, at no level, has the Constituional authority to be involved in the private lives of American citizens, including their marriages or other relationships. Any other interpretation is the promotion of something all of you claim to hate, that is to say, and which your own words openly admit, you are actively promoting that which you claim to hate, which is statist control of your lives and the legalization of government tyranny over your own lives.

67

Rocks, your suggestion that the word "identical" in the second part implies a separate object being compared to the first ("identical to marriage, but not marriage as it was just defined") defies the text and the plain meaning of the word "identical." The text does not say, "identical or similar to marriage, but not marriage as it was just defined." It says "identical or similar to marriage." Identical. As in, "the same."

 

68 to me, it doesn't so much ban marriage, as it would technically remove government's involvement in marriage - i.e. no more marriages before judges (creation) and no more special benefits associated with it (recognition).  It doesn't say marriage is illegal, it just says the state cannot create nor show preference towards any marriage-like status... sort of like the 1st amendment when it comes to religion.

Generally, I'd say I'm cool with that... but that would open up a whole new can of worms... polygamy, child marriages, etc.

69 I disagree with your "textual" reading.It bans something identical or similar to marriage. It doesn't ban something that is marriage.

70 I seem to recall a dim memory from law school of a principal of statutory construction that says if a statute is reasonably subject to two interpretations, one of which nullifies the entire purpose of the statute, the court will apply the interpretation that is consistent with the clear purpose of the statute. 

71 68 to me, it doesn't so much ban marriage, as it would technically remove government's involvement in marriage - i.e. no more marriages before judges (creation) and no more special benefits associated with it (recognition).  It doesn't say marriage is illegal, it just says the state cannot create nor show preference towards any marriage-like status... sort of like the 1st amendment when it comes to religion.

Posted by: A.G. at November 19, 2009 12:09 PM (jBPzC)

That sounds like the best explanation yet.

72 (A) Definition: Marriage is between a man and a woman.

(B) Proscription: The state shall not recognize legal statuses identical to marriage.

Commenters are reading an implicit "other" in subpart B ("The state shall not recognize other legal statuses"), because they know the intent of the amendment. The point of my original post is that the text alone does not get you there.

But, the only thing "identical" to marriage is marriage, so even if you put the "other" in, then the words still carry the exact same meaning. If you want to be pedantic about this, then it is not just the word "other" that is missing, but the word "equivalent" that should replace "identical". "Identical" indicates identity, which is true for nothing but the actual object, itself.

Of course, this is what we get when we let people who don't know logic formulate and interpret law that is supposed to be logically-based.

73 Posted by: Gabriel Malor at November 19, 2009 11:50 AM (nPZxi)

And what is the meaning of "the same"? Gabe how can something be identical to itself? What is used to make the comparison when you only have one? "The same" as what? Only more than one of something can be "the same". Determining something is "the same" means you have made a comparison.

Identical, "the same" does not mean singular, which is what would be required for what you are suggesting to be true. Two objects may be "the same" in every way, shape and form of comparison, but they are not the same singular thing.
They are 2 things which are "the same".

You have a hammer. You can certainly say the object sitting next to it is "the same" and is therefore a hammer. But making the statement that everything identical to your hammer is not a hammer doesn't cause your hammer to no longer be a hammer. If it did that would mean there is no hammer. But yet you can bang nails all day with your non-hammer.

For what you are suggesting to be true the clause must first be rendered illogical.

74 Gabe how can something be identical to itself?

Posted by: Rocks at November 19, 2009 12:42 PM (Q1lie) An object is identical to nothing but itself. Both you and Gabe are wildly mistaken in your understandings of the meaning of "identical".

75 Texas has a Whorehouse in it!!

Lord have mercy on our souls!

76 "This state or a political subdivision of this state may not create or recognize any legal status identical or similar to marriage."

Breaking it down:

..may not create any legal status identical or similar to marriage.  - no problem
..may not recognize any legal status similar to marriage.  - no problem
..may not recognize any legal status identical to marriage. - no problem

Does NOT say - may not recognize the legal status of marriage. 

English much?

77

So, yes, Texas banned marriage

Oh, baby, wait till I tell my wife of 28 years this little nugget. It's all over, no more taking out the trash, raking the freaking leaves, or trying to find the remote she put somewhere because it looked better there than where I always leave it. Yippee!

78 Posted by: progressoverpeace at November 19, 2009 12:48 PM (A46hP)

2  one ounce bars of 100% pure gold are identical but can have a different identity. They exist separately from each other. So, I have no idea what you are getting at here.

79 2 one ounce bars of 100% pure gold are identical but can have a different identity. They exist separately from each other. So, I have no idea what you are getting at here.

Posted by: Rocks at November 19, 2009 12:56 PM (Q1lie)

Incorrect. The two bars are identical "in value", or "in nature", but they are not "identical". There are many differences between them. They are only "identical" within some constrained context, which is what I have been saying.

The Texas statute states identity in "legal status", which takes care of that issue, unlike Gabe's example at the end of the post, which just states "identical" as objects.

Again, the correct term should be "equivalent" and the "other" needs to be included - since equivalence is reflexive. The "identical" in the statute is totally useless.

80 As far as any rewrite to the clause I would suggest adding the word "other" does nothing. Using "other" would suggest there are legal statuses which could be identical or similar legally to marriage and then ban them. It would give legal status and take it away in one breath. Very bad. Instead:

"This state or a political subdivision of this state may not create or recognize any legal status AS identical or similar to marriage."

This puts the comparison in it's proper place which is when the state would attempt to create or recognize a legal status, not after and would clearly set off marriage for those who seem to have such a problem with the very plain statement as it is already written.

81 The "identical" in the statute is totally useless.

Posted by: progressoverpeace at November 19, 2009 01:04 PM (A46hP)

By your definition identical is useless in any statement, not just this statue.

Perhaps you should start a movement to eliminate it's usage.

82 By your definition identical is useless in any statement, not just this statue.

Posted by: Rocks at November 19, 2009 01:11 PM (Q1lie)

Not at all. My point is that "identical" (with respect to legal status) is superfluous in this statute, since "similar" (with respect to legal status) includes identity.

83 "Identical" indicates identity, which is true for nothing but the actual object, itself.

Posted by: progressoverpeace at November 19, 2009 12:17 PM (A46hP)

 

That is absurb. Separate things can be identical, otherwise the meaning of the term is vitiated and the term irrelevant.

84

Not at all. My point is that "identical" (with respect to legal status) is superfluous in this statute, since "similar" (with respect to legal status) includes identity.

Posted by: progressoverpeace at November 19, 2009 01:17 PM (A46hP)

 

Identical and similar are different levels of "same-ness".

85 That is absurb. Separate things can be identical, otherwise the meaning of the term is vitiated and the term irrelevant.

Posted by: gm at November 19, 2009 01:18 PM (qhDcz)

Only within restricted contexts. If you take the gold bar example above, they are identical with respect to size? Well, that is impossible - though we can allow for a certain context of scale in that determnination. Are they identical in temperature? You are assuming that. You are are assuming that two different objects are identical, not as objects, but only within some restricted comparison, since there will always be some determination for which they differ. But to be identical, there must be NO DIFFERENCES. This can only be achieved for separate objects by restricting the comparison.

86 If you call a union between a man and a woman with x rights a marriage, it is a marriage. If you call a union between a man and a woman with x rights a monkey, it is identical to a marriage.

87

The term is necessary, however, because some enterprising lawyer may say that a same-sex union with x rights is not similar to a marriage because it has the same rights. Instead, they may argue, it is identical with a marriage. Without the identical or similar terminology, he case is easier to make. Use of both terms limits the ability of an activist judge of finding in favor of such an argument.

88 Would 2 bars of the same weight, length, height and comprised entirely of 100% gold atoms  aligned in exactly the same crystalline structure sitting in the same room at the exact same time be considered identical? Or does even the parts of their atoms need to move in exact synchronization?

You are rendering the use of the word identical as meaningless.

Reality is a restricted context.

89

Well, lets say yes. They outlawed any state recognition of marriage or similar unions and benefits.

So.....?

I mean, Oh noes! Whatever would I do without an official state certificate.

90 Identical and similar are different levels of "same-ness".

Posted by: gm at November 19, 2009 01:21 PM (qhDcz)

Yes. All identical objects are similar but similar objects are not necessarily identical. Once they include "similar", "identical" is unnecessary. That's all I was saying.

The term is necessary, however, because some enterprising lawyer may say that a same-sex union with x rights is not similar to a marriage because it has the same rights. Instead, they may argue, it is identical with a marriage. Without the identical or similar terminology, he case is easier to make. Use of both terms limits the ability of an activist judge of finding in favor of such an argument.

Posted by: gm at November 19, 2009 01:28 PM (qhDcz)

I don't argue with your point, here, but this is the problem with our legal system and the lack of logic - or even common sense understanding - in a field that requires a logical basis for its continued utility. The use of "similar" covers "identical" in any hard science. It is only in law, and soft sciences, that there would be a problem with such simple concepts.

I am never more disgusted with humanity than when I read judicial decisions and the "reasoning" behind them. They violate just about every law of logic and good sense - changing scales arbitrarily, being pedantic about isolated issues while ignoring similar (or even identical!) problems elsewhere in the same case, twisting the definitions of words into unrecognizable forms, attributing definitions to terms at will, ...

91

It says so right in the Bible.

If the State of Texas does not recognize and ordain your marriage, it is unholy.

Thou shalt not know a woman in your bed without the approval of the King of the Lone Stars, chosen by God Allmighty as His authority on Earth.

92 You are rendering the use of the word identical as meaningless.

Reality is a restricted context.

Posted by: Rocks at November 19, 2009 01:31 PM (Q1lie)

I'm just saying that "identity" needs to be qualified, as it is in the Texas statute, and as I did with the gold bars ('in value'). Often, this qualification is implicit and publicly understood, but it is still there.

93

Rick Perry is like the protestant Pope.

Which is just like the Catholic Pope, except without the bubble car.

94

Not at all. My point is that "identical" (with respect to legal status) is superfluous in this statute, since "similar" (with respect to legal status) includes identity.

Posted by: progressoverpeace at November 19, 2009 01:17 PM (A46hP)

I would agree with GM. It's not superfluous, it's mandatory.

Suggesting unions other  than a man and a woman are "identical" in every respect except genders is exactly what judges have used to determine that recognition of same-sex unions are required under Equal Protection clauses.  This statue would make it clear that no part of the state can suggest that they are identical or similar to marriage.

95 And 32% less italian.

96

People in comments seem to think it's mere "lawyering" to believe that if Texas had defined something in subpart A of the amendment that it could not have then banned it in subpart B. Except, of course, that's how laws get written all the time.

People are right, it is mere lawyering.  Only it's not "mere."  IT'S WHAT LAWYERS DO.

That's why, lots of times, we elect really smart lawyers, like Obama, to legislatures, because legislatures make laws, and ought to sit around and ponder word choice carefully BEFORE making said laws.

97 Identical is in no way a subset of similar in any effing science! 

(from The American Heritage Dictionary - paperback, what I have near to hand)

Identical - being exactly equal and alike
Similar  -  showing some resemblance; alike though not identical

98 Suggesting unions other than a man and a woman are "identical" in every respect except genders is exactly what judges have used to determine that recognition of same-sex unions are required under Equal Protection clauses.

Posted by: Rocks at November 19, 2009 01:41 PM (Q1lie)

Equal Protection rulings are among the worst that Mankind has ever seen. The idiocy involved in the bulk of them is enough to make the Rain Man blush. (On a side note, it's funny that many Equal Protection cases show no direct harm to any individual but plaintiffs are granted standing, whereas having a usurper in the Oval Office - which carries clear harm to every single citizen - has been granted no standing in any court) When judges are that stupid and belligerent, then adding any number of superfluous qualifications is not going to stop them. They'll just redefine, or ignore, whatever they want to arrive at their pre-ordained decisions, anyway.

I hate to break it to you, no wording of any statute will stop judges from arbitrarily imposing their will, if that is their intention. Considering that we have officially decided, as a nation, that empathy is a legitimate qualification for a SCOTUS justice, I don't hold out much hope for our judiciary doing anything correctly. But my point on 'similar' including 'identical' stands.

99

After grinding my way through this thread, I can only conclude thus:

 

Less Laywers

 

More cowbell!

 

mac :]

100

what part of the Constitution claims to give the federal and state governments the authority to 'legalize' marriage and define "domestic unions"?

 

The Constitution places very few restrictions on the state governments, as opposed to the federal. But this is in theory. In practice the Constitution has been a dead letter since the seventies at least.

101

Whoops - spellcheck is my friend. And proper grammar.

Less lawyers!

More cowbell!

mac :]

102 Way cool! Kelly and I are still living in sin according to this.

103 97 Identical is in no way a subset of similar in any effing science!

Identical triangles are similar.

(from The American Heritage Dictionary - paperback, what I have near to hand)

Identical - being exactly equal and alike

Similar - showing some resemblance; alike though not identical

Posted by: somejoe at November 19, 2009 01:44 PM (SSWdi)

Similar angles are the

Merriam-Webster - Similar:

1 : having characteristics in common : strictly comparable

2 : alike in substance or essentials

Dueling dictionaries.

104

In practice the Constitution has been a dead letter since the seventies at least.

No it hasn't.  It's just that we're the only ones who know what it says.

105

As with most things legal, an ounce of preparation is worth a pound of litigation.  If you start with clear and harmonious language, you avoid future problems.  The Texas amendment should stick, but one wishes they'd been more careful with their wording in the first place.

I'd argue that what we have here is a case of under-lawyering rather than over-lawyering.  For those who think this isn't significant, imagine you are Antonin Scalia III in 2109 trying to divine the intent of the Texas amendment.  The "plain language" is where you start, and you only look to statements of "legislative intent" where the language doesn't provide the answer.  Fortunately in this case that would get you where you need to go, but the fact remains that this contradictory phrasing could (and should) have been easily avoided.

106 I think that the government should get out of the business of approving marriages in the first place.

A marriage is either a solemn promise between two people, in which case the state is a 3rd party and has no standing in the matter; or it is a contract, in which case the state's only role is to enforce the terms of that contract. 

Laws can and should be written to define what constitutes a legal contract, but aside from this the state shouldn't be involved.  If I enter into a contract with someone, I don't need to get a license from the state to do it.  I don't need to go before a justice of the peace and have a little ceremony to certify the contract.  If there is a dispute I may need to hire a lawyer and go to court, but in such a case I am asking the state to intercede.  The state is not all up in my business from the get go.

I still say that gay marriage is just a political football, something for cultural traditionalists / social authoritarians and post modernists / Marxists to beat each other up with.  It is well chosen for this role because of how irrelevant it is.  It affects no one but gay people, who make up about 2% of the population on a good day.

The less real impact an issue has on people's lives, the more extreme the partisanship will be over it, and the less likely the issue is to ever be resolved.  Were it to be resolved, the antagonists would have to find some other irrelevancy to bitch about and defame one another over.

It is the same with the death penalty.  Who is affected by the death penalty?  Convicted murderers, their families, and the families of their victims.  That excludes 99.9% of the population right there.  Yet there is no end to the tongue wagging and finger pointing being done over it. 

The things in life that actually matter are usually those things that there is the least contention about.  The more fussing and fighting and carrying on there is about something, the less likely it is to actually matter.

107 Posted by: somejoe at November 19, 2009 01:44 PM (SSWdi)

So ... the standard phrase, "They are not just/merely similar, they are identical," is incorrect usage, in your view?

Look through SCOTUS rulings and you will find "similar" and "similarly" used when "identical" is subsumed into the context - i.e. identical action/behavior/process would not rule out what the court is dictating for "similar".

108 #9 by Rocks nails it.  It's not about "other".  The one exists: marriage.  The law says you cannot recognize anything similar or identical to that which exists already.  "Other" is a Clintonian wedge formation to crack the obvious mathematic logic of the statement as it stands.

Drop the "other" and read the actual logic.  The beauty of the logic is that it even prevents redefinition of that which exists--marriage--because it treats it as an a priori and immutable fact.

109 I'm sure someone has already posted this, but, if not, here goes:  actually, the law doesn't ban marriage.  Even textually.  It talks about "any legal status identical or similar to marriage."  The key words are *identical* and *similar.*  These are important, because they directly differentiate the status in question from the status of marriage.  Thus, the status in question cannot be identical or similar to marriage.  Even textually, it explicitly deals with a status that is NOT, be definition, marriage.

the sinner,

Patrick

110 Nope, I'm an idiot.  Sorry for wasting anyone's time.  I see it - the thing is, as a lawyer, I'm too use to trying to find the language and *use* it for a particular decision.  When I jumped out of character for a second, I finally saw the point.  Understood, and quite funny, really.  This *does* happen all the time, unfortunately!  Anyone else following the insanity behind the Consumer Protection Act, or whatever, regarding the lead in child toys?  I guess, recently, the committee that is supposed to enforce it found that absolutely no toys/objects would meet the exemption that was written into the law.  Yeah, we lawyers suck.  Big time.

the sinner,

Patrick

111 So how f'in stupid does someone have to be to not understand that:
1) X is legal only in circumstances Y and Z
2) J, even if it is similar to X, will not be legal.

Seems extremely clear cut. Marriage between a man and woman are legal; anything similar to marriage is not legal. How does one cancel the other?

Answer: It doesn't.  This is just some cuntstain democrat running for office trying to make hay while the sun is shining.  Too bad her head is crammed where the sun don't shine.

112

So how f'in stupid does someone have to be to not understand that:
1) X is legal only in circumstances Y and Z
2) J, even if it is similar to X, will not be legal.

Except that it doesn't actually say that, baboy. It says:
(1) X is defined.
(2) Legal statuses identical to X will not be created or recognized in the state of Texas.

They meant what you wrote. But they didn't actually vote for that.

113 Ok, now I'm just "dithering."  Seriously, looking at the language again, one could very well say that using the terms *identical* and *similar* necessarily mean they are not, in fact, marriage, as defined. 

So, yes:  A: Marriage is defined.
B: outlines what is illegal - anything that is identical or similar to Marriage.  However, if the law meant marriage, it would have said marriage.  Not something identical or similar to.

I guess you could see it both ways, really.  If you define the word *identical* to mean marriage, you could very well say that it does, in fact, outlaw marriage between a man and a woman.  On the other hand, by the very fact that the law uses the term *identical*, it is attempting to draw a distinction between that what the law is attempting to declare is illegal and that which is defined.

The illustration of laws defining things and then declaring them illegal in another section does happen, but every time (in California, any way) the subsequent section, the one that does the actual declarin' of illegality, says "X, as defined in section Y."  This law does not do that. 

Again, I guess you can simply see it either way.

the sinner,

Patrick

114

Classic time travel paradox.

If marriage is illegal because there can be no legal status identical to marriage, then there is no legal status of marriage to be identical to.

115

"The point of my original post is that the text alone does not get you there."

 

Sure it does.  ""This state or a political subdivision of this state may not create or recognize any legal status of identical twins or people similar to Gabriel."  If Gabriel has an identical twin running around out there, the state will not recognize his legal status.  This statement has nothing to do with Gabriel himself.  Of course, we would have to be able to distinguish between the two twins, which is why we name them (subpart A).  We recognize Gabriel.  Accept no substitute, identical or otherwise.

116 Wonder if this means my wife and I are living in sin now?

117 So how f'in stupid does someone have to be to not understand that:
1) X is legal only in circumstances Y and Z
2) J, even if it is similar to X, will not be legal.

118 which ones do you suggest? I've been hurtin' ever since I heard even my beloved NCIS made fun of Palin.

119 Again, I guess you can simply see it either way.

120 burberry scarf | CD Keys

121
One can easily imagine Baker et al in the footwear of the contemporary designers on view at the exhibit: towering snakeskin boots by Jimmy Choo, beaded black-and-orange lace-up Manolo Blahnik sandals, and the wickedly high-beaded Christian Louboutin pumps made even sassier with their signature red soles. Great shoes transcend eras.

122 Everyone says  Christian Louboutin beautiful, and I know. . A few days ago a blind a walk on the Internet are not careful Liu Dadao This Web http://www.christianlouboutinshoes.me, a look at so many good-looking, bought a pair of shoes to a friend, I am pretty good quality, but I find the prices a bit expensive We go to see if it is expensive ah, and now it hurts!

123 شات الرياض دليل شات الرياض الدردشة شاتات دردشات شات حلا السعوديه

124 mbt cheap
mbt sale
mbt uk
mbt shoes cheap
buy mbt shoes
shoes mbt sale

125 Chipotle Mexican Grill links of london jewellery . The fast food at these casual links of london eateries feels slow, links london jewelry thanks to organic ingredients cheap links of london , custom combos, link of london and an emphasis on freshness. links of london sale Traffic is down at many locations, links of london jewelry but the company has been able to compensate by raising prices, links london Olive Garden. links of london Charms More food for less money hits the sweet spot these days, links of london Charm which makes the family-style portions at this casual Italian chain a hit with diners. links of london Necklaces Olive Garden is a division of Darden Restaurants, links london Necklace which also operates Red Lobster, links of london Bracelets Longhorn Steakhouse, links london Bracelet and a few smaller chains. links of london Sweetie Bracelets Olive Garden has been the best performer of the bunch, links london Sweetie Bracelet with same-store sales down slightly but overall sales up, links of london Friendship Bracelets thanks to about 35 new outlets links of london Sweetie Watches that have opened over the past year links london Friendship Bracelet

126 منتديات موقع حواء للبنات للبنات استضافة بنات السعودية بنت سعودية مطير النوادر يوتيوب عالم الحب الحياة الزوجية هوامير ملوك العرب تفسير الاحلام صور كتب شات معلومات العاب بنات بث مباشر طبخ العاب طب نكت دروس دليل ماسنجر جوال قصص ستلايت سكربتات شعر رسائل برنامج ترجمة تحميل افلام شات صوتي افلام بنات العاب للبنات فقط لعبة جديدة بروكسي سمو الحب ليل الحب فوركس بلاك بيري توبيكات بنات شات بنات شات الرياض

127 The proper function of man is to live, but not to exist.ugg classic cardyConquer fear of death and you are put into possession of your life. ugg classic tallThere is a time to speak and a time to be silent. ugg knightsbridgefree shippingmbt cheap
mbt sale
mbt uk
mbt shoes cheap
MBT M.Walk

128 hot news for brand shoes online store ,do you want to win more discount ?and popular for younger,and nike air maxwith top quality A ,come on all air max shoes with lowest price for highest quality !

129 Everything dynamic and very positively!
Ugg Classic Cardy,discount, free shipping!

130 The cheap ugg boots sale for women are stylish, they are comfortable and what،¯s more, they keep your feet. theres a pair of fellow sufferers,ugg australia uk to complement your personal preferences, why do we not take the traditional high discount ugg boots on salefor cold winter?
As a matter of fact, with the passing time, the love for ugg usa is increasing among girls in this modern world. The growing demand for these womens ugg made the manufacturers UGG Boots Sale to revamp the looks of these boots with different hues.come our website and buy a pair of ugg uk.UGG Classic Cardy are popular as shoes for cowboys. The SHOES close the whole parts of the foot. The ugg cardy are important to protect your feet from any dangerous things during your walking activities. There are many oatmeal ugg available in the Market and if you are interested to get one you can directly go to the store that sells it.

131 Tiffany On Sale is a famous tiffany Jewelry store which sell directly Tiffany Rings, Necklaces, Errings, Bracelets and other Tiffany Jewellery. provide the highest quality ttiffany jewelry at rather competitive prices.Please feel free to browse our selection, and contact us with any questions that you may have. Since 2005 We have done online tiffanys Jewelry business from now on and we have many cusotmers from USA, Europe,India and other countries. Buying from here will save you lots of money and get high quality Tiffany Jewelry

132 Stunning silver jewellery from tiffany, Gucci, Links of London; quality designer silver jewelry at online prices. We have silver Bracelets, Solid Silver ...

Shop creations of timeless beauty from cheap tiffany jewelrythat will be treasured always. You can buy cheap tiffany jewelry but high quality from us

tiffany s.'s reviews of local businesses in Seattle, Bend, Florence and beyond on Yelp.

133

توبيكات ، أناشيد طيور الجنه ،قصائد كتابيه ، قصائد مسموعه ، خواطر ، قصص روايات ،أزياء ، فساتين  ، مكياج ، خلطات ، تسريحات ، ديكور ، ديكورات ، حلويات ، معجنات ، نادي الهلال ، نادي النصر ، نادي الاتحاد ، سيارات ، موديلات سيارات ،أزياء ادم ، إنمي ،أفلام انمي ، صور طبيعيه ، سينما ، افلام ، مسلسلات رمضانيه ، صور فنانين ، صور ممثلين ، صور مطربين ، مسلسل عاصي ، زفات ، اغاني بدون موسيقى ، كلمات اغاني  ، ماسنجر ، سكربتات ، ثيمات ماسنجر ، برامج للماسنجر ، صور ماسنجر ، صور بنات للماسنجر ، صور شباب للماسنجر  ، توبيك ، نكات ، توبيكات اغاني ، توبيكات كرتونيه ، توبيكات ملونه ، برامج فوتوشوب ، خلفيات للتصميم ، صور للتصميم ، خامات ، فلاتر ، اكشن ،فلاتر ، سكرابز ، خطوط ، باترن ، فرش ، جلتر ، سويتش ، فلاش ، ملفات مفتوحه ، ملف مفتوح  ، جوال ، برامج جوال ، ثيمات جوال ، العاب جوال ، بلوتوث ، نغمات جوال ، يوتيوب ، رسائل ،mms ، sms ، مسجات ، وسائط اغاني ، برامج كمبيوتر ، العاب كمبيوتر ، العاب بنات ، منتدى ، منتديات ، وتلومني فيك ، شبكة وتلومني فيك

كلمات أغاني خالد عبدالرحمن كلمات البوم خالد عبدالرحمن كلمات البوم روح روحي
ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن قلبك كبير أغاني ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن قلبك كبير كلمات أغاني ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن قلبك كبير
ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن فرحة لقانا أغاني ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن فرحة لقانا كلمات ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن فرحة لقانا
ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن عقد وسوار أغاني ألبوم خالد عبد الرحمن عقد وسوار كلمات ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن عقد وسوار
ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن البوم خالد عبدالرحمن سامريات - من يسد بمكانه كلمات أغاني البوم سامريات - من يسد بمكانه
ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن البوم خالد عبدالرحمن بقايا جروح كلمات أغاني البوم بقايا جروح
ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن صفحة جديدة أغاني ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن صفحة جديدة كلمات ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن صفحة جديدة
ألبوم خالد عبدالرحمن البوم خالد عبدالرحمن إفراق كلمات أغاني البوم خالد عبدالرحم إفراق
كلمات أغنية شلونك حبيبي ، تحميل أغنية شلونك حبيبي ، شلونك حبيبي ، كلمات اغاني البوم ماجد مهندس 2009
كلمات البوم الوسمي 2009 كلمات أغاني البوم مالك حل 2009‏
كلمات اغنية الفنانه سميه الخشاب عايزاك كده كلمات اغنية سميه الخشاب عايزاك كده 2009
كلمات اغاني راشد الماجد 2009 كلمات جديد راشد الماجد 2009 جميع اغاني راشد الماجد كلمات اغاني راشد 2009
كلمات اغاني الفنان عبد المجيد عبدالله كلمات اغاني البوم روحي تحبك كلمات اغنية روحي تحبك كلمات اغنية مسموح كلمات اغنية عين كلمات اغنية من اول افرح كلمات اغنية حبايبنا
أغنية عاد عيدك حبيبي ، تحميل أغنية عاد عيدك ، كلمات أغنية عاد عيدك حبيبي ، أغاني راشد الماجد
أغنية ياشرطي ، تحميل أغنية ياشرطي ، كلمات أغنية ياشرطي ، ياشرطي كلم حبيبي
زفات ديانا حداد بدون موسيقى ، زفات ديانا حداد ، زفات أغاني ديانا حداد 2009‏
كلمات أغنية انا انسانه كلمات أغاني البوم يارا 2009 تحميل أغنية أنا انسانه
زفة أغنية خلي عينك تناظر ، زفة خلي عينك تناظر ، زفات عرايس ، زفات عروس ، زفات 2009
كلمات أغاني أروى 2009 كلمات البوم غصب عنك 2009 البوم اروى غصب عنك 2009‏
أغنية منت رايق بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية منت رايق بدون موسيقى
زفة مذهله ، زفة أغنية مذهله ، زفة أغاني محمد عبده 2009 ، زفة مذهله محمد عبده
أغنية ياغداره ، كلمات أغنية ياغداره ، تحميل أغنية ياغداره ، ياغداره ، أغاني راشد الماجد 2009
أغنية اعذريني بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية اعذريني بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغاني بدون موسيقى
أغنية أسافر عنك بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية أسافر عنك بدون موسيقى
اغاني بدون موسيقى ، عزه ياقلبي من الهم ، اغنية عزه بدون موسيقى ، اغاني راشد الفارس بدون موسيقى
زفة طل القمر ، زفة أغنية طل القمر ، زفة طل القمر 2009 ، زفة أغنية طل القمر 2009
رفة أغنية المشكله أغنية المشكله بدون موسيقى أغنية المشكله بصوت موضي أغاني بصوت موضي
أغنية غاب صوتك بدون موسيقى ، تحميل اغنية غاب صوتك بدون موسيقى ، أغاني فارس مهدي بدون موسيقى
زفة ياقمر سلم ، زفات إسلاميه ، زفات خليجيه ، زفات أغنية اقمر سلم ، زفات بدون موسيقى
اسرار العيون . محمد عبده . بدون موسيقى زفه روعه
زفة أغلى عروس ، زفة أغنية أغلى عروس ، زفات عرايس ، زفات زواج
كلمات البوم الفنانه يارا 2009 لالى خليجيه كلمات اغنية انا انسانه كلمات اغنية بكل شي تجذب كلمات اغنية تذكر يوم كلمات اغنية راغبه مني كلمات اغنية سكر زياده كلمات اغنية سلمولي كلمات اغنية مارو
كلمات اغنية راشد الفارس شي ثاني ، كلمات اغنية شي ثاني ، كلمات البوم, راشد الفارس شي ثاني
أغنية وين احب الليله بدون موسيقى ، كلمات أغنية وين احب الليله ، أغاني محمد عبده 2010
أغنية تقوى الهجر بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية تقوى الهجر بدون موسيقى
زفة نور الشمس ، زفة أغنية نور الشمس ، زفات للعرايس
أغنية مشتاق قالولي بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية مشتاق قالولي بدون موسيقى ، أغاني بدون موسيقى
زفة لا تقولون ، زفة أغنية لا تقولون ، زفات أغاني محمد عبده ، زفات محمد عبده
أغاني ماجد مهندس بدون موسيقى أغنية ست الحبايب بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية ست الحبايب بدون موسيقى
أغاني ماجد مهندس أغنية فوق الشوق بدون موسيقى تحميل أغنية فوق الشوق بدون موسيقى
اغنية اكثر من اول بدون موسيقى اغنية احلام بدون موسيقى اغنية اكثر من اول
أغنية حبيبي اسف ازعجتك بدون موسيقى ، أغاني خالد عبدالرحمن بدون موسيقى
زفة قمر واحلى زفات روعه زفة بصوت عيسى الماجد زفه باسم ساره‏
زفة الله ياحلوه ، زفة الأميره ساره ، زفات إسلاميه ، زفة الله ياحلوه بدون موسيقى
اغنية دلوعتي بدون موسيقى زفة اغنية دلوعتي بدون موسيقى اغنية الفنان راشد الماجد زفه حلوه
أغنية روح وروح بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية روح وروح بدون موسيقى ، أغاني أصاله بدون موسيقى
اغنية خاينه بصوت هند البلوشي بدون موسيقى
زغاريد زغروطه زغروته زغروته طويله زغروته قصيره
اغنية جيبه يعني اجيبه لو كان تحت الحراسه بدون موسيقى
أغنية أنا حبيبي بدون موسيقى ، أغاني فارس مهدي بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية أنا حبيبي بدون موسيقى
اغنية لايق عليك الورد زفة لايق عليك الورد اغنية لايق عليك الورد بدون موسيقى زفة لايق عليك الورد للعرايس
ويلاه ضاق الصدر وما ذكر يسأل علي بدون موسيقى
أغنية جنه جنه بدون موسيقى ، كلمات أغنية جنه جنه ، تحميل أغنية جنه جنه بدون موسيقى
زفات أغاني محمد عبده 2009 ، زفة عذبة الأطباع ، زفات محمد عبده ، زفة عذبة الاطباع 2009
زفة أموت بحبك ، أغنية أموت بحبك بدون موسيقى ، زفات عبدالمجيد عبدالله 2009 ، زفات أغاني عبدالمجيد عبدالله 2009 ، زفة أغنية أموت بحبك 2009‏
أغنية تعب قلبي بدون موسيقى ، أغاني نوال الكويتي بدون موسيقى ، كلمات أغنية تعب قلبي
اغاني الجسمي بدون موسيقى ، اغنية فقدك بدون موسيقى ، اغاني الجسمي فقدك بدون موسيقى
اغنية اجيك يسلم راسك وشلون ماجيك بدون موسيقى
القوس قوسك والسهام سهامك بصوت طقاقه بدون موسيقى اغنيه جديده اغنيه 2009
اغنية صدفه ليارا بدون موسيقى اغنية صدفه ومن بين كل الناس حبيتك بالدف
أغاني أحلام بدون موسيقى ، أغاني البومات أحلام ، أغاني احلام بدون موسيقى 2009 ، أغاني بدون موسيقى
أغنية يالي على البال بصوت موضي ، زفة ياللي على البال بدون موسيقى ، أغاني موضي الشمري بدون موسيقى
اغنية انت طيب بدون موسيقى اغنية نوال بدون موسيقى اغنية انت طيب اغنية نوال الكويتيه انت طيب‏
أغنية يعجبني الزعل بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية يعجبني الزعل بدون موسيقى ، أغاني نوال الكويتيه بدون موسيقى
أغنية بين أيدي بدون موسيقى ، أغنية بين ايديا بدون موسيقى ، أغاني ماجد مهندس بدون موسيقى
أغنية ليلي الم بدون موسيقى ، أغنية ليلي ألم بدون موسيقى
زفة احلى عروس راشد الماجد بدون موسيقى
أغنية قول أمين بدون موسيقى ، زفة قول امين بدون موسيقى ، زفات عبدالمجيد عبدالله ، زفة قول امين
أغنية ياقلبي بدون موسيقى تحميل أغنية ياقلبي بدون موسيقى أغاني ماجد مهندس بدون موسيقى
اغنيه مرتاح ولا يتصنع قلبك الراحه بدون موسيقى ، تحميل اغنيه مرتاح ولا يتصنع قلبك الراحه بدون موسيقى ، أغاني أحلام 2009
زفة أحلى من القمر ، زفة أغنية أحلى من القمر ، زفة أغاني راشد الفارس ، زفات أغاني راشد الفارس
أغنية انا وخلي بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية انا وخلي بدون موسيقى
أغنية الا يامطوله صبري بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية الا يامطوله صبري بدون موسيقى
أغنية لو يقولون انتي حلوه بدون موسيقى ، كلمات أغنية إنتي حلوه ، أغاني رابح صقر بدون موسيقى
أغنية أجمل إنسانه ، أغنية أجمل إنسانه بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية أجمل إنسانه بدون موسيقى
زفة السندريلا ، زفة أغنية السندريلا ، زفات إسلاميه ، زفات عرايس
أغنية ناويلك على نيه ، زفات أحلام ، زفات أغاني أحلام بدون موسيقى ، زفات أفراح
أغنية هلي لا تحرموني منه بدون موسيقى ، أغاني راشد الماجد 2009 بدون موسيقى ، أغنية هلي لا تحرموني منه
أغنية أبي حبك معي يكبر بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية أبي حبك معي يكبر بدون موسيقى ، أغاني بدون موسيقى 2009
أغنية انت منت انسان أكثر بدون موسيقى ، تحميل انت منت انسان أكثر بدون موسيقى ، أغاني عبدالمجيد بدون موسيقى
اغنية العنب العنب أغاني عبير التركي أغنية العنب بصوت عبير التركي أغاني طقاقات
أغنية تحس فيني بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية تحس فيني بدون موسيقى ، أغاني أحلام بدون موسيقى ، أغنية تحس فيني أحلام بدون موسيقى‏
أغاني أحلام بدون موسيقى ، أغاني البومات أحلام ، أغاني احلام بدون موسيقى 2009 ، أغاني بدون موسيقى
أغنية والله واحشني موت بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية والله واحشني موت بدون موسيقى ، أغاني ماجد مهندس بدون موسيقى
زفة دقو المزاهر، زفات مصريه ، زفة أغنية دقو المزاهر ، زفات أغاني مصريه
اغنية غنو لحبيبي بدون موسيقى اغنية عبد المجيد عبدالله بدون موسيقى اغنية غنو لحبيبي
أغنية اليوم طالع قمر ، زفة اليوم طالع قمر ، زفات عبدالمجيد عبدالله ، زفة اليوم طالع قمر بدون موسيقى ، زفات عبدالمجيد عبدالله بدون موسيقى‏
أغنية نور عيني بدون موسيقى أغنية حبنا يا نور عيني لا يضيع أغاني راشد الماجد بدون موسيقى
زفات طقاقات بدون موسيقى 2009 ، زفات طق بدون موسيقى 2009 ، تحميل طقاقات 2009 ، تحميل طقاقات بدون موسيقى 2009‏
زفات جديده زفه بصوت روعه زفه كامله زفات 2009‏
زفات أغاني راشد الماجد زفات بالاسماء زفات أغاني راشد الماجد بالاسماء زفات راشد 2009
أغنية روح وروح بدون موسيقى ، أغاني أصاله بدون موسيقى ، أغنية روح وروح ، أغاني بدون موسيقى
كلمات اغاني البوم هيفاء وهبي الجديد بابا فين 2010 كلمات اغاني هيفاء وهبي الجديده بابا فين ولما تغيب الشمس
أغنية الحكايه بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية الحكايه بدون موسيقى
اغنية إندماج الارواح بدون موسيقى ، كلمات أغنية إندماج الارواح ، أغنية إندماج الارواح ، أغاني فارس بدون موسيقى
أغنية عزاه بدون موسيقى تحميل أغنية عزاه بدون موسيقى تحميل أغاني راشد الفارس بدون موسيقى
اغنية عسى دايم نكون احباب اغنية عبد المجيد عبد الله اغنيه بدون موسيقى
اغنية رقصهم وشعللهم ، اغنية رقصهم وشعللهم بدون موسيقى ، رقصهم وشعللهم على المسرح شويه شويه
اغنية من يقول اني لغيرك اغنية راشد الماجد اغنيه بدون موسيقى اغنيه حلوه
أغنية لا تخاف من الزمان بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية لا تخاف من الزمان ، أغاني أصاله بدون موسيقى
اغنية رنيت لك رنه بدون موسيقى ، تنزيل اغنية رنيت لك رنه بدون موسيقى ، اغنيه رنيت لك رنه
اغنية في منتهى الرقه بدون موسيقى ,كلمات اغنية في منتهى الرقه بدون موسيقى ,اغنية رابح صقر بمنتهى الرقه بدون موسيقى
اغنية والله احبك بدون موسيقى ,كلمات اغنية والله احبك ,اغنية والله احبك بصوت اشواق ,اغنية والله احبك بدون موسيقى ,اغنية الفنان يوسف العماني والله احبك
أغنية صدفه بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية صدفه بدون موسيقى ، أغاني يارا بدون موسيقى‏
زفة احلى نهار ، زفة خطوة خجل ، زفات راشد الماجد 2009 زفة أغنية أحلى نهار ، زفة أغنية خطوة خجل
أغنية الأماكن بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية الأماكن بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغاني محمد عبده بدون موسيقى‏
أغاني محمد عبده بدون موسيقى ، أغنية إختلفنا بدون موسيقى ، كلمات أغنية إختلفنا
زفات حسين الجسمي زفات الجسمي زفات حسين الجسمي بدون موسيقى
زفة رشو الورود ، زفات سوريه ، زفات أغاني سوريا ، زفة أغنية رشو الورود
أغنية تكفون بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية تكفون بدون موسيقى أغاني بدون موسيقى‏
أغنية خاينه وما تنصفي بدون موسيقى تحميل اغنية خاينه وما تنصفي أغاني مغربيه بدون موسيقى
أغنية الحب خالد بدون موسيقى ، أغاني بدون موسيقى ، أغنية الحب خالد
اغنية انكسرت الشيشه بدون موسيقى ، انكسرت الشيشه بدون موسيقى ، انكسرت الشيشه
اغنية اميرة الورد بدون موسيقى زفة اميرة الورد بدون موسيقى اغنية الفنان محمد عبده زفه رائعه
اغنية قوم ودرج لي وارقص قدامي بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية قوم ودرج لي وارقص قدامي بدون موسيقى ، أغاني الطقاقه العنود بدن موسيقى‏
أغاني اليازيه محمد بدون موسيقى ، أغنية برق لمع بدون موسيقى ، أغنية متغير علي بدون موسيقى ، أغنية تهددني بدون موسيقى
أغنية انا صاحي لهم بدون موسيقى ، كلمات أغنية أنا صاحي لهم ، أغاني راشد الماجد صوتيه بدون موسيقى
أغنية يلوموني حبيبي فيك بدون موسيقى أغاني راشد الماجد بدون موسيقى2009 البوم نور عيني بدون موسيقى أغاني بدون موسيقى‏
زفات العروس 2009 ، زفات للعروس 2009 ، زفات خليجية للعروس 2009 ، زفة عروس 2009
أغنية طالعه من بيت أبوها بدون موسيقى ، أغنية طالعه من بيت ابوها بصوت ماجد مهندس ، أغاني بدون موسيقى
أغنية معجبه بدون موسيقى ، أغاني بدون موسيقى ، أغنية معجبه 2009 بدون موسيقى
اغنية وش جاه بدون موسيقى ، تحميل اغنية وش جاه بدون موسيقى ، اغاني البوم نور عيني بدون موسيقى
زفة غنت الاشعار زفات 2009 زفه كامله زفه جديده
أغنية عشان الحب بدون موسيقى ، كلمات أغنية عشان الحب ، تحميل أغنية عشان الحب ، اغاني راشد الماجد بدون موسيقى
أغاني صوتيه بدون موسيقى ، أغنية مشكلتي اهواه بدون موسيقى ، أغاني زيد الزايد بدون موسيقى
زفات عرائس زفة أميرة الورد تحميل زفة أميرة الورد تحميل زفات إسلاميه
زفه شعريه زفه بصوت روعه زفات شعريه زفه بصوت عبدالله السعدي
زفات كويتيه ، زفات مصريه ، زفات هنديه ، زفات اسلاميه ، زفات تركيه ، زفات انجليزيه ، زفات بحرينيه ، زفات سعوديه
زفة اقبلت احلى البنات حسين الجسمي زفه روعه
أغنية لقيت غيرك بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية لقيت غيرك ، أغاني تامر حسني بدون موسيقى ، أغاني بدون موسيقى
أغنية سواها قلبي يا حبيبي وحبك بدون موسيقى ، تحميل اغنية سواها قلبي يا حبيبي وحبك ، اغاني بدون موسيقى
زفه البدر لراشد الماجد بدون موسيقى‏
مؤثرات صوتيه ، زغاريط ، زغاريط افراح ، زغاريط للزفات ، زغاريط بدون موسيقى ، زغرطه
أغاني البوم روح روحي بدون موسيقى ، أغنية خلص حنانك بدون موسيقى ، أغاني عبدالمجيد عبدالله بدون موسيقى
اغنية الحب خالد بدون موسيقى ,اغنية راشد الماجد بدون موسيقى ,اغنيه الحب خالد بدون موسيقى
زفات حسين الجسمي ، زفات أغاني حسين الجسمي ، زفة حلوة واموره للجسمي ، زفات أغاني حسين الجسمي بدون موسيقى
اغنية مليون خاطر بدون موسيقى ,كلمات اغنية مليون خاطر ,اغنية عبد المجيد عبد الله مليون خاطر , تحميل اغنية مليون خاطر بدون موسيقى‏
أغنية القوس قوسك بدون موسيقى تحميل أغنية القوس قوسك بدون موسيقى أغاني عبدالمجيد عبدالله بدون موسيقى
اغنية ياحبني لك بدون موسيقى ,كلمات اغنية ياحبني لك بدون موسيقى ,اغنية ماجد المهندس ياحبني لك بدون موسيقى ,تحميل اغنية ياحبني لك بدون موسيقى
أغنية يغار قلبي بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية يغار قلبي بدون موسيقى ، أغاني راشد الماجد بدون موسيقى ، أغنية يغار قلبي راشد الماجد‏
أغنية الدنيا حلوه بدون موسيقى ، أغاني نانسي عجرم بدون موسيقى ، كلمات أغنية نانسي عجرم
أغاني بدون موسيقى تحميل اغنيه يعشقني بدون موسيقى اغنيه يعشقني
أغاني الطقاقه العنود ، أغاني زواج بدون موسيقى ، أغاني الطقاقه العنود بدون موسيقى ، اغاني أعراس بدون موسيقى‏
اغنية مابنكسر صابر بدون موسيقى ، أغنية مابنكسر صابر بصوت ماجد بدون موسيقى ، مابنكسر صابر بدون موسيقى
اغنية ياحظ عينك بدون موسيقى ، كلمات اغنية ياحظ عينك ، أغاني عبدالمجيد عبدالله بدون موسيقى
اغاني بدون موسيقه اغنية المهلي مايولي اغاني محمد الزيلعي اغنيه بدون مسيقى
أغنية تلفت الناس لامريت بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية تلفت الناس لامريت بدون موسيقى
زفة خذها امانه ، أغنية خذها أمانه بدون موسيقى ، زفات بدون موسيقى ، زفة خذها أمانه بدون موسيقى
أغنية الي لقى احبابه بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية الي لقى احبابه بدون موسيقى
أغنية الريش بدون موسيقى ، اغاني راشد الماجد 2009 بدون موسيقى ، أغاني البوم نور عيني بدون موسيقى
اكبر مجموعة اغاني بدون موسيقى 2009 ، اغاني بدون موسيقى لجميع الفنانين ، اغاني بدون موسيقى للتحميل
اغنية اليوم طالع قمر اغنيه بدون موسيقى اغنيه حلوه
أغنية على كثر السنين بدون موسيقى أغاني راشد الماجد 2009 بدون موسيقى تحميل أغنية على كثر السنين
اغنية والله واحشني زمانك بدون موسيقى ، كلمات اغنية والله واحشني زمانك ، والله واحشني زمانك بدون موسيقى‏
أغاني نوال الكويتيه بدون موسيقى أغنية من البدايه بدون موسيقى ، أغنية ليش أزعل عليك بدون موسيقى ، أغنية سامحتك بدون موسيقى
زفة ممشاها حرير ، زفة أغنية ممشاها حرير ، زفات أغاني حسين الجسمي 2009 ، زفات الجسمي للعرايس
زفه روعه زفات جديده زفه بصوت سلوم السلوم
أغنية ساعات بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية ساعات بدون موسيقى ، أغاني راشد الماجد بدون موسيقى
أغاني البوم نور عيني بدون موسيقى أغنية ويلاه بدون موسيقى تحميل أغنية ويلاه بدون موسيقى
أغنية ياسلام عليكم يالسعوديه ، أغاني راشد الماجد بدون موسيقى ، أغنية ياسلام عليكم ياسعوديه بدون موسيقى
أغاني بدون موسيقى أغنية مرحبا بقدوم خلي بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية مرحبا بقدوم خلي بدون موسيقى
أغنية اه منك منقهر ، تحميل أغنية اه منك منقهر ، كلمات أغنية اه منك منقهر ، جديد أغاني راشد الماجد
أغنية أنا حبيبي بدون موسيقى ، أغاني فارس مهدي بدون موسيقى ، تحميل أغنية أنا حبيبي بدون موسيقى
أغنية بلا حب بلا وجع قلب بدون موسيقى ، كلمات بلا حب بلا وجع قلب ، أغاني راشد الماجد 2009 بدون موسيقى‏
كلمات اغنية انا من حقي اغير للفنان راشد الماجد 2010 كلمات البوم راشد الماجد 2010 كلمات اغاني الفنان راشد الماجد 2010‏
كلمات اغنية البيت مايسوى بدونك سعد الفهد 2010 ، اغنية البيت مايسوى بدونك 2010
اغاني بدون موسيقى ، اغاني زفات بدون موسيقى ، اغاني طقاقات بدون موسيقى ، اغاني فنانيين بدون موسيقى ، تحميل اغاني بدون موسيقى
زفات عرايس ، أغاني زفات ، زفات للأفراح ، زفات أغاني إسلاميه ، زفات 2010
اغنية لبيه يالحد الجنوبي ، كلمات اغنية راشد الماجد لبيه يالحد الجنوبي ، كلمات اغنية لبيه يالحد الجنوبي
مؤثرات صوتيه للزفات ، اصوات طبيعيه للزفات ، اصوات بشريه للزفات ، اصوات منوعه للزفات

البوم مني امرشا سنة اولي حب 2010 , اغنية اي شوق , اغنية بدالك الف , اغنية تبي تقنعني , اغنية حلم او علم

اغنية الموعد الضايع ، كلمات اغنية الموعد الضايع ، تحميل اغنية الموعد الضايع ، الموعد الضايع راشد الماجد ويارا ، اغنية الموعد الضايع راشد الماجد ويارا

اغنية غرقان لراشدالماجد،اغنية راشدالماجدوحسين الجسمي،اغنية غرقان،غرقان2010

134 discount YSL Platform Pumps&Slingbacks

135 $75 Replica Rolex Watches sale, Our site provides Rolex replica,  replica Rolex Watches, replica breitling, replica Cartier, replica Omega, Tag Heuer Watches. . .more than 100 famous rolex brands"
rolex air king
rolex datejust
rolex day date

136

ugg bailey button     ugg classic mini

137 cheap nike shox shoes

138 Today ugg boots online have become a phenomenon.Every winter,the ugg classic crochet are one of the hottest goods in the market all over the world.So now don't be hesitation,own a pair of ugg usa immediately.

139 Our bags are premium , not to confuse our replica handbags by fake big brand bags from other websites. It is nearly the same as Original, so exact you will need a professional to tell the differences between Our Bags,

140 We supply authentic discount Lacoste Shoes
Lacoste Trainers
New Lacoste
Lacoste Sale
Mens Lacoste
camden lacoste trainers
lacoste trainers shoes
lacoste camden retro
camden lacoste trainers
lacoste carnaby shoes
lacoste carnaby retro
lacoste shoes sale
New Lacoste shoes
Lacoste shoes online
cheap Lacoste shoes
Lacoste shoe
mens lacoste shoes
Lacoste Shua Lace
Black Lace shoes
white Lace shoes
lacoste swerve shoes
White Lacoste shoes
Lacoste shoes sale
Cheap Lacoste shoes
Lacoste Women Shoes
Women Lacoste Shoes
Lacoste Shoes online
on line, cheap price,Top quality,Free shipping!

141

UGG 30th Anniversary

UGG Bailey Button boots

UGG Classic Argyle Knit 5806

UGG Classic Cardy boots

UGG Classic Short boots

UGG Classic Tall /black/chestnut/chocolate/grey/sand boots

UGG Classic Mini boots

UGG Classic Crochet boots

UGG Classic Metallic boots

UGG Sundance II boots

UGG Nightfall boots

UGG Suede Boot

UGG Upside boots

UGG Ultra Short boots

UGG Ultra Tall boots

UGG Classic 5816

UGG Classic 5817

UGG Roxy 5818 boots

cheap / discount women's ugg boots on sale free shipping 2009/2010

142 Gold Pendants Yiwu | Watches | Titanium Bracelets Fashion | Tungsten Rings | Wholesale Plating Bangles Jewelry | Carbon Pendants Cheap | Gold Tungsten Wholesale | Plating Necklace | Wholesal Hermes Jewelry | Carbon Fiber Bangle Luxury | Tiffany And Co Cheap | Stainless Steel Bracelet Best | Wholesale Laser Earring Jewelry | Key Ring Luxury | Tiffanys Fashion | Cutting Bracelet Yiwu | Stamping Bracelet Cheap | Stamping Necklaces | Wholesal Hermes Jewelry | Earrings Cheap

143 Wholesal Pendants Tiffany | Tiffany Sale Best | Jewelry Tools Yiwu | Tiffany&Co Bangle Best | Money Clips Best | Stone Rings Yiwu | Tiffanys Luxury | Rubber Bangles Cheap | Plating Earring | Tungsten Bracelet Wholesale | Wire Bangle | Plating Necklace Fashion | Stamping Necklace Luxury | Ceramic Bracelet Yiwu | Wholesal Magnet Bracelet | Casting Bracelets Fashion | Cutting Tungsten Bracelet Cheap | Jewelry Tool Best | Wholesal Plating Cufflink | Small Necklace

144 Shopping for a Rolex watch online can tag heuer make the job Rolex Watches easier but you Replica Watches also have to be patek philippe wary about the reputation of the dealer Chanel Watches and the brand of Breitling Watches watch you are audemars piguet getting. The more mont blanc watches considerable you are, the less danger you would come to armani watches when buying a Omega Watches gold watch online.

145 Buy rolex Fake Watches and Replica Watches brands,rolex watches rolex watches, Replica rolex watches, replica rolex: replica rolex,replica rolex: replica breitling watches,replica tag heuer: replica tag heuer,replica cartier watches: replica cartier watches,replica omega watches: replica omega watches,replica panerai watches: replica panerai watches,replica armani watches: replica armani watches,replica audemars piguet: replica audemars piguet,replica bvlgari watches: replica bvlgari watches,replica chanel watches: replica chanel watches,replica gucci watches: replica gucci watches,replica movado watches: replica movado watches,replica montblanc watches: replica montblanc watches,replica patek philippe: replica patek philippe on sale.

146 Bulova Replica Watches | Watches Technomarine Fashion | Replica Breitling Watches | IWC Replica Watches | Replica Gucci Watches | Replica TAG Heuer Watches | Ulysse Nardin Fake Watches | Franck Muller Fake Watches | Watches Bedat & CO Fashion | Ulysse Nardin Fake Watches | Raymond Weil Fake Watches | Replica Oris Watches | Replica Swiss Watches | Replica Juicy Couture Watches | Watches Gucci Fashion | Rado Fake Watches | Technomarine Replica Watches | Replica TAG Heuer Watches | Breitling Fake Watches | Replica Breitling Watches

147 Life lies in sports.The Air max wants to offer you great comfort while you doing sports.Cheap nike air max shoes is on sale now.The Air max 90 and Nike air max 95 is a good nike shoes for you.You can Buy nike max here,Discount air maxs and Cheap nike air max 2009 waiting for you.

148

Piaget watches

Rado watches

Tag Heuer watches

Tudor watches

watcehs

149 I recommend you go to online store, there have a lot of ugg boots sale,If you want to buy a pair of cheap ugg boots uk.More and more people choose ugg boots uk. So you know that ugg series of the most famous is the ugg boots.

150 Hello,everybody.The user has to tell the framework when the dynamically generated response has changed.And nothing else to say.Yous everything goes well.

151

Today,get a good shoes to a people is more and more important.Let me tell you something about MBT shoes.MBT Anti Shoes have been known as “the world’s smallest gym”.Since they increase muscle activity,strenthening and toning of the leg,buttock,stomach and back muscles takes place during everyday activities like walking and standing.

Since celebrities like Cher,Gwyneth Paltrow,and Heidi Klum have reportedly added Anti Shoes to their shoe collection,MBT Shoes have received a lot of press.Their unique design has supposedly help wearer’s tone up,lose weight,and even smooth cellulite,and it has garnered the brand a lot of attention as well.

Shop your MBT Anti Shoes on Showcu of Mbt Shoes Sale.We are the stockist of Cheap Anti Shoes.Our Anti Gravity Shoes Sale in huge stock.You can enjoy Free Shipping on our MBT Anti UK and MBT US.Buy Now!

152 ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظپظٹط¯ظٹظˆ News Politics ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط£ط¯ط¨ ظˆط´ط¹ط± ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط£ظ†ط§ط´ظٹط¯ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط§ظ„ط±ط­ط§ظٹط§ ط­ط¬ط± ط§ظ„ظ‚ظ„ظˆط¨ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط¨ط§ط¨ ط§ظ„ط­ط§ط±ط© 4 ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط¨ط±ط§ظ…ط¬ طھظ„ظپط²ظٹظˆظ† ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط¨ط±ظ†ط§ظ…ط¬ ظ„ظ…ط§ط°ط§ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط¨ظٹطھ ط¬ط¯ظٹ 2 ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ… ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط­ط±ط¨ ط§ظ„ط¬ظˆط§ط³ظٹط³ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط­ظپظ„ط§طھ ط§ظ„ظ…ط³ط±ط­ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط¯ظ‚ط§طھ ظ‚ظ„ط¨ 2 ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط±ط§ط¬ظ„ ظˆط³طھ ط³طھط§طھ 5 ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط±ط¬ط§ظ„ ط§ظ„ط­ط³ظ… ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط±ظٹط§ط¶ط© ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط²ظ…ظ† ط§ظ„ط¹ط§ط± ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط³ظپط± ط§ظ„ط­ط¬ط§ط±ط© ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط³ظٹط§ط­ط© ظˆط³ظپط± ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ط¹ظ„ظˆظ… ظˆطھظƒظ†ظˆظ„ظˆط¬ظٹط§ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظپظ†ط¬ط§ظ† ط§ظ„ط¯ظ… ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظپظ†ظˆظ† ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظ‚ط¨ط§ط¦ظ„ ط§ظ„ط´ط±ظ‚ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظƒظˆظ…ظٹط¯ظٹط§ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظ…ط³ظ„ط³ظ„ ط§ظ„ط­ط¨ ط§ظ„ظ…ط³طھط­ظٹظ„ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظ…ط³ظ„ط³ظ„ ط¬ظˆط§ظ‡ط± ط§ظ„طھط±ظƒظٹ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظ…ط³ظ„ط³ظ„ طµط¨ط§ظٹط§ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظ…ط³ظ„ط³ظ„ ط¹ط§طµظٹ ط§ظ„طھط±ظƒظٹ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظ…ط³ظ„ط³ظ„ ظ…ط§ ط§طھط®ط§ظپظˆط´ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظ…ط³ظ„ط³ظ„ط§طھ ط±ظ…ط¶ط§ظ† 2009 ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظ…ظˆط³ظٹظ‚ظ‰ ظˆط£ط؛ط§ظ†ظٹ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظ‡ط¯ظˆط، ظ†ط³ط¨ظٹ ظٹظˆطھظٹظˆط¨ ظˆط§ط¯ظٹ ط§ظ„ط°ط¦ط§ط¨ 3

153 Replica rolex watches,tag heuer watches and replica rolex watches,replica watches replica breitling watches breitling watches,chanel watches chanel watches replica patek philippe patek philippe watches,replica audemars piguet watches replica montblanc watches for men and women.

154 Replica fake watches and replica watches brands,rolex watches rolex watches, replica rolex: replica rolex,replica rolex: breitling watches,replica tag heuer: tag heuer,replica cartier watches: cartier watches,replica omega watches: omega watches,replica panerai watches: replica panerai watches,replica armani watches: replica armani watches,replica audemars piguet: replica audemars piguet,replica bvlgari watches: replica bvlgari watches,replica chanel watches: replica chanel watches,replica gucci watches: replica gucci watches,replica movado watches: replica movado watches,replica montblanc watches: replica montblanc watches,replica patek philippe: replica patek philippe sale.Replica rolex watches and tag heuer watches, rolex watches,Replica Watches replica watches,patek philippe patek philippe Watches,audemars piguet audemars piguet,Omega Watches: omega watches,replica Cartier Watches cartier watches,Breitling Watches breitling watches,Chanel Watches: chanel watches,armani watches: armani watches,iwc watches iwc watches,mont blanc watches montblanc watches.

155 We sell rolex and tag heuer watch, rolex watches,Rolex replica watches,replica patek philippe Watches,replica audemars piguet,Omega Watches omega watches,replica Cartier cartier watches,Breitling breitling watches,replica chanel watches,armani watches: armani watches,iwc watches iwc watches,montblanc montblanc watches Replica.Cheap fake watches and replica watches on sale,rolex watches rolex watches, watches replica rolex,replica breitling watches,replica tag heuer: tag heuer,replica cartier watches: cartier watches,replica omega watches: omega watches,replica panerai watches: replica panerai watches,replica armani watches: replica armani watches,replica audemars piguet: replica audemars piguet,replica bvlgari watches: replica bvlgari watches,replica chanel watches: replica chanel watches,replica gucci watches: replica gucci watches,replica movado watches: replica movado watches,replica montblanc watches: replica montblanc watches,replica patek philippe: replica patek philippe sale for people.

156 If you want presents for your best friends. Links London store will be the best chose for you. Top Links of London supply lots of jewelry at our online store. You can،¯t find such enjoyable collection of Links London anywhere else.

157 Cheap replica rolex and tag heuer watches,replica watches of rolex rolex watches replica,buy patek philippe Buy replica watches,fake watches and tag heuer watches.

158 There is a good place which provide wholesale Links of London. All kinds of Links of London jewelry are offered here. What 's more,buy our cheap Links of London jewelry for wholesale give you chance of discount and even free gifts. Come here to enjoy your favorit jewelry!

159 replica rolex rolex and tag heuer watches,replica watches of rolex rolex watches replica,buy patek philippe Buy replica watches,fake watches and tag heuer watches.breitling watches breitling watches at low price.

160 UGG cardy
Ugg Australia
Ugg Shoes Sale
Bailey Button
ugg boots
Ugg classic cardy
UGG cardy
Ugg Australia
Ugg Shoes Sale
Bailey Button
ugg boots

161 links london Pendants is at discount now.Links London products have cheap price here,You may also interested at links london Rings and links london Sweetie Bracelets.

162 Un total de once comunidades autnomas estn este jueves en alerta naranja Christmas gift ugg tall boots (riesgo importante) por nevadas y bajan las temperaturas en toda Espa09a, segn la Agencia Estatal de Meteorologa (AEMET). En concreto, se Christmas gift ugg napoule sandal trata de Aragn, Cantabria, Castilla-La Mancha, Catalu09a, Christmas gift timberland classic boots Madrid, Navarra, Comunidad Valenciana, Galicia, Pas Vasco, Asturias y Murcia. La cota de nieve bajar a menos de 200 metros en el CantbricoLa Pennsula Ibrica est bajo dos borrascas y un anticicln que crearn un pasillo que permitir el paso de una corriente de aire muy fro, como la que est provocando un temporal de fro glaciar en Europa, aunque es esperan que el fro que suframos no sea tan intenso como en otros pases. An as, se espera que las bajas temperaturas se mantengan hasta el domingo. La cota de nieve baja en el Cantbrico a menos de 200 metros

163 Links London 2010 NEW ARRIVALS is most favored by people at our online store. Links London jewelry store also offers Links London Bracelets and Links London Earrings .

164 Links London Jewelry is a famous brand that has quality of fashion style and classic charm. The wholesale Links of London is cheap and more fashion style. So Links london Store is your best choice. links of london 2010 NEW ARRIVALS, links of london Bracelets , links of london Charms , links of london Earrings , links of london Friendship , links of london Necklaces , links london sweetie , links london Rings , links london Bracelets , links of london chains, links of london watches , links of london Accessories .

165 Have you have ever heard the term "runescape accounts"? How about, "runescape gold"? They have many names, but they are all the same. Although I know exactly what a macro is in Runescape, I thought I would do some research and see what a macro was outside of runescape gold for sale. Macroing in runescape accounts for saleBasically, when you use a buy runescape gold, you are using a program that will play the game for you. There are many different types of these, such as; Mining Bots, Woodcutting Bots, Attacking Bots, but they all do the same thing, get levels. This is against the rules of runescape quests help. Jagex bans thousands of accounts a month due to these cheats. I cannot tell people enough, cheating is NOT the answer. If people would just do the work themselves, then there would be no problem. Macroing outside of runescape power leveling:As I promised, I researched and this is what I found; "A macro is a way to automate a task that you perform repeatedly or on a regular basis. It is a series of runescape money making commands and actions that can be stored and run whenever you need to perform the task. You can record or build a macro, and then play the macro to automatically repeat the series of commands or actions."

166 hostgator coupon - hostgator review - hostgator reseller coupon - fatcow review - fastdomain review - hostmonster coupon - hostmonster review - fastdomain coupon - fatcow coupon - bluehost coupon - bluehost review

167 Do you want to win more discount ? Links of London Discount save you a lot. High quality Links London Friendship Bracelet are offered at our online store. Links London sale is waiting for you choice£، links of london Accessories, links london chains , links london necklaces , links london rings , links london sweetie , links london bracelets , links london charms , links london earrings , links london watches.

168 Hair Straightener
chi hair straightener
chi flat irons
chi iron
best hair straightener
ceramic hair straightener
flat iron
pink chi hair
chi hair irons
ghd
Pink GHI Hair
GHD
GHD MK4
GHD MK5
Pink GHD
Pink GHI Hair
CHI Flat Irons
Hair Straightener
chi hair irons
chi hair straightener
best hair straightener
chi hair iron
pink chi hair
chi hair irons
Pink GHI Hair
Pink GHD
GHD
Nike Kobe Shoes
Nike Lebron Shoes
discount nike shox shoes

169 Support by UK shopping links of London earrings was intuitive and nowadays we have matured internationally with stores in 1990.links of londonThe party resulted from a clean exact for her wife, links londonJohn Ayton, founded the jewelry mark,links of london sale Links of London. Relations of London were founded in the UK, Hong Kong, links of london charms USA and Canada.links of london charms Links of London is one of the chief jewelry brands in the United Kingdom.links of london sweetie bracelet It lays a lot of weight on producing jewelry featuring newer, exceptional designs.It has been reported that silver tiffany & co was regularly melted to oxidization are general accessories. links of london braceletJewelry designs however did not been fixed

170 junxiao:Are you  to our nike air force ones store online in which you can find most kinds of air force shoes with lowair force 1 low,air force one mid,Men's Nike AF1 Bird's Nest Shoes ,Men's Nike AF1 Light-up Shoes ,Men's Nike AF1 Olympic Shoes ect.

171 Good replica watches and buy replica watches and replica rolex replica replica tag heuer watches,buy replica replica omega watches and breitling watches replica breitling watches sale at lowest prices.

172

حواء

شات

دردشة

يوتيوب

youtube

يوتيوب مسلسلات وبرامج
 

يوتيوب عالم الحيوان

يوتيوب الرياضه

يوتيوب الشعر والمقناص
 

يوتيوب الكرتون

يوتيوب إسلامي

يوتيوب غرائب وعجائب

يوتيوب طرائف

يوتيوب المسرحيات

يوتيوب سيارات ومركبات

مستر بين

أفلام اجنبية
 

أفلام عربية

يوتيوب تسلية وترفية

يوتيوب عالم حواء
 

بث مباشر للقنوات

يوتيوب أخر الأخبار

دروس وشورحات
 

يوتيوب اغاني
 

يوتيوب أفلام هندية مدبلجة

يوتيوب افلام وثائقية

وسائط mms - توبيكات -القران الكريم- دليل - صور ماسنجر -تردد القنوات - العاب

يوتيوب عالم الحيوان ,  يوتيوب الرياضه ,  يوتيوب الشعر والمقناص  , يوتيوب مسلسلات وبرامج  , يوتيوب الكرتون ,  يوتيوب إسلامي  , يوتيوب غرائب وعجائب  , يوتيوب طرائف  , يوتيوب المسرحيات  , يوتيوب سيارات ومركبات ,  مستر بين  , أفلام اجنبية  , أفلام عربية  , يوتيوب تسلية وترفية  , يوتيوب عالم حواء  , بث مباشر للقنوات,افلام هندية مدبلجة , افلام وثائقية

173 nike air max 360 shoes
womens air max
nike air max
womens air max
nike air max 360 shoes
air max
kids air max 90
kids air max classic BW
kids air max 360
kids air max 97
nike air max 180
nike air max 2009
nike air max 2010
nike air max 360 shoes
nike air max 87
nike air max 88
nike air max 89
nike air max 90
nike air max 91
nike air max 93
nike air max 95
nike air max classic BW
nike air max ltd
nike air max TN
womens air max 2007
womens air max 2009
womens air max 87
womens air max 90
womens air max 91
womens air max 95
womens air max 97
womens air max classic BW

174 breitling watch Ladies watches at Gilletts Jewellers include like Eco Drive Citizen watches replica watch There are a few ways you rolex watches omega watches can try replica watches Fossil watches DKNY watches Michael Ks watches breitling watches

175 replica handbags Wholesale products louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton handbags beautiful wholesale handbags louis vuitton replica handbags wholesale jewelry wholesale clothing from factory louis vuitton handbags with cheap wholesale price

176 Buy rolex replica watches and replica watches replica replica watches and replica rolex watches patek philippe watches and fake watches and breitling watches,replica tag heuer: tag heuer,replica cartier watches: cartier watches,replica omega watches: omega watches at lowest prices.

177 Today it looks very intriguing, prohibitively worldwide.

178 It is no secret that the designer handbag market is extremely profitable designer handbags are one of the most sought after items by women wholesale handbags replica handbags However louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton handbags if you are like me you probably know that finding legitimate louis vuitton handbags wholesalers of designer handbags is not easy to say the least louis vuitton handbags

179 cheap online shopping/ hot holiday toys/ discount electronic stores/ best selling toys/ department stores online/ deluxescan/ inwdigg

180 nike max
air max shoes
nike air max
nike max shoes
air max 1
nike air max 1
air max 2
nike air max 2
air max 89
nike air max 89
air max 90
nike air max 90
air max 91
nike air max 91
air max 95
nike air max 95
air max 97
nike air max 97
air max 180
nike air max 180
air max 360
nike air max 360
air max 2003
nike air max 2003
air max 2009
nike air max 2009
air max ltd
nike air max ltd
air max tn
nike air max tn
air max tailwind
nike air max tailwind
womens air max 1
womens air max 90
womens air max 95
womens air max BW
womens air max LTD
womens air max TN
womens air max 360
womens air max 2003
womens air max 2007
womens air max 2009

181 wholesale handbags louis vuitton It is no secret that the designer handbag market is extremely profitable designer handbags are one of the most sought wholesale handbags after items by women louis vuitton However if you louis vuitton handbags are like me you probably know that finding legitimate louis vuitton handbags wholesalers of designer handbags is not easy to say the least

182 louis vuitton replica handbags replica handbags Buy cheap replica Louis Vuitton Handbags Louis Vuitton Bags from HandbagsAir We have the most LV Bags Louis Vuitton Gucci Chanel wholesale handbags Miu Miu styles louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton

183 Replica Handbags have provide replica omega watches replica omega watches the high quality Replica AUDEMARS PIGUET all brand handbags We have the especial price a especial production including coach handbags omega watches replica cartier Replica tag heuer

184 coach purses are lots of replica coach purses available ed hardy shirts ed hardy Shoes,Paco Chicano Clothing Abercrombie and Fitch best online abercrombie and fitch shop ed hardy t-shirt Official Ed Hardy Online Shop - offering Cheap jordan shoes the best cheap deals on jordan shoes chi flat iron revolution with the iconic Farouk CHI flat iron nike tn chaussures nike shox rivalry,nike tn nike air max we offer original nike air max shoes air max 90 retail air max 90 from our online store buy gucci buy high quality cheap gucci Jewellery here chanel handbags chanel Handbags,my chanel store is best chanel bags Visit our active Chanel bag forum chanel purses reese-witherspoon-chanel-purse.jpg ed hardy shirts We supply Cheap Ed Hardy shirts ed hardy t shirt We supply Cheap Ed Hardy shirt for kids Cartier glasses WholeSale cartier glasses eyeglasses frames Cartier jewelry discount Cartier jewellery with latest design Coach purses global coach purses manufacturers, suppliers Cheap coach purses a replcia purses suppliers of cheap coach purses Coach hangbags manufacturers, coach hangbags suppliers Discount coach Discount Coach Bag - 3725 results like Ghd straightener The ghd hair straighteners are certainly ghd flat iron Should you buy the GHD flat iron christian louboutin shoes offering range of Christian Louboutin shoes air max 90 Buy Air Max 90 from our online store puma shoes Buy Puma Shoes from our online store, free shipping Cheap Gucci sunglasses these cheap Gucci sunglasses are still cutting Cheap prada sunglasses wholesale cheap Prada sunglasses, Coach, Gucci Cheap D&G sunglasses discount sunglasses at Cheap D&G sunglasses Discount Gucci sunglasses At Eyesave you get great discount Gucci Sunglasses. Discount prada sunglasses These discount Prada sunglass styles are Discount D&G sunglasses At Eyesave you get great discount D & G Sunglasses

185 Certainly watches are Replica Watches used to help people record rolex Watches time, but rolex watches nowadays its functions have enlarged. Replica watches are now tag heuer Watches not only objects that tag heuer watches can tell you what time it is, they are also a status symbol. You should not feel strange when you find someone wearing a watch on his wrist, but use the cell phone to tell time. In that situation, the watch is just showing its luxurious function cartier watches. It is normal and cartier watches perhaps also happens to you. .If asked that among the watches of various brands, which one can suit your taste? There is no doubt that most people will choose Rolex. Whichever social class you are in, it is naturally Rolex was known breitling Watches and cherished breitling watches for a long time. However, the elements do not usually enter the market alone, always come with the price tag up to the hand. For this reason, many people, especially men, their dreams of luxury Rolex watches are buried in omega Watches his heart omega watches. What should I do? Rolex watches are simply stunning worn by the rich and famous, right? No, this world is not the world's richest men, is the world of each. All are equal before the search of luxury and be men's watches respected. Within men's watches, the law, when consumers are in the market, women's watches they should women's watches receive the same treatment. This is the real reason why replica Rolex watches are ladies watches ladies watches more welcome than Rolex. Because in this world are not difficult to understand that the rich are much less than people with low income, you agree with me? You are forced to nod and say with certainty that is the reality. These low-income people do not have enough money to save every month. They can not afford such luxury Rolex watches

186 vacheron constantin watches Cheap high quality Louis Vuitton Replica AUDEMARS PIGUET Louis Vuitton HandbagsLV bagslouis vuitton luggage Replica omega chanel handbags replica movado gucci handbags omega watches replica movado LV Discoutn Replica Handbags On

187 Special Cheap Discount Wedding Collection:
Cheap Wedding Dresses
Cheap Wedding Gowns
Beach Wedding Dresses
Color Wedding Dresses
Plus Size Wedding Dresses
Wedding Dresses Styles
Special Occasion Dresses
Cocktail Dresses
Party Dresses
Prom Dresses
Mother of the Bride Dresses
Flower Girl Dresses
Bridesmaid Dresses

188 Cheap replica watches and replica watches 100% copy replica watches of the previous omega watches model: the famous Manchester Logo is located at 3 and the cartier watches chronograph 45-minute breitling watches at 9 with orange figures. Football fans can use the very special 45-minute chronograph to measure the halves of a football match. Black patek philippe hour hand and minute hand features yellow luminescent coating. The hour makers, chronograph audemars piguet and the first 15-minute scale of the tag heuer chronograph counter is montblanc watches presented in eye-catching rolex red. Bright Yellow movado watches tones are found on the minute track, date bvlgari watches rolex on sale.

189 Valentine،¯s Day is coming! Will you prepare Valentine،¯s day gift for your lover£؟Links of London Gift is the best choice for you. Wearing Links London Jewelry makes your lover out of ordinary in a crowd. Hurry up please! Go shopping for Links of London silver. links of london 2010 NEW ARRIVALS. links of london friendship . links of london chains . links of London necklaces. links of london rings . links of london sweetie. links of london bracelets . links of london charms . links of london earrings . links of london watches .

190 umniki
Upcoming
mamba Jankoi
blog
masseur
Rich with something
Tol7tik
Partner
the fastest cars
boxer of the world
And yes will forgive me Google

191 nike max
air max shoes
nike air max
nike max shoes
air max 1
nike air max 1
air max 2
nike air max 2
air max 89
nike air max 89
air max 90
nike air max 90
air max 91
nike air max 91
air max 95
nike air max 95
air max 97
nike air max 97
air max 180
nike air max 180
air max 360
nike air max 360
air max 2003
nike air max 2003
air max 2009
nike air max 2009

192 TAG HEUER Watches ROLEX Watches OMEGA Watches CARTIER Watches Luxury Cartier watches are available at Essential Watches at discounted prices At Essential Watches we specialize in replica Watches OMEGA Watches all high end watch lines including

193 this replica watches replica watchWhoever wants replica watches timekeeper that does the job of a tachometer will be crazy for. The operation is performed by the copied replica rolex 's bezel. The Daytona also applies automatic movement ¨C just one of many breitling watches characters and functionalities that ensures the precision of time. Originally created to measure lap time and the cartier watches overall time of a race, Rolex Daytona replica omega watches timepieces can measure elapsed time for omega any sporting event. The power of this breitling replica item is made possibly by its internalized perpetual rotor mechanism. Known for its precision, this special Rolex replica cartier watch model only has to be set once to the cartier watches standard time of the owner's choice. Once rolex watches being created, it updates itself during time changes, making upkeep of the replica's time setting replica watches nonexistent. Even though these replica watches were made for sporting events, (specifically those involving laps or circuits), it's not so adversible to put them tag heuer in water since they are not fake watches waterproof. Even thought most of the time, the replica watches do not bear the tag heuer same functionalities as the original ones, they are still the most desirable alternatives of the expensive real models.

194 Factors Replica Watches About The Rolex replica watches Oyster The Oyster is so closely get in touch with Rolex, and it is inevitably that some people think these are the only Replica watches Rolex manufacture. Others suppose that there is a single Oyster watch. But as a matter of fact, the name Oyster does not actually meant for a rolex Watches particular watch you can buy rolex watches or even to a series but to a type of case that available in some of the Rolex ranges. History The Oyster case was first released in 1926. The objective was to protect the workings of the watch from dust and moisture. Early watches were far from waterproof. The Oyster tag heuer Watchescase was an tag heuer watches innovative design to eliminate these problems. It had a new double locking crown that screwed into place. It has been compared to the hatch on a submarine. Like a submarine, the Oyster case was waterproof. In 1927 Mercedes Gleitze swam the English breitling Watches Channel breitling watches . Before she set off she was presented with a Rolex Oyster. When she arrived, the watch was still working perfectly. The resulting publicity gave the new case a massive boost. Why is it called Oyster? Legend has it that Hans cartier Watches Wilsdorf cartier watches, who invented the Oyster, chose the name because the new case reminded him of the difficulty he had experienced prising open oysters at dinner. Since then the Oyster has further, particularly advanced. Many Oyster watches today are omega Watches perpetual-self-winding, in other omega watches words, it does not require to expose the mechanism to the outside world in order to wind it. The Osyter Perpetual is one of the toughest, most durable, most reliable watches (under truly adverse conditions). It is probably the best mechanical watch money can buy.

195 Cartier watches at ShopStyle TAG HEUER Watches Shop popular ROLEX Watches TAG HEUER Watches ROLEX Watches to find cartier watches on sale all in one place Create OMEGA Watches share looks based on all your OMEGA Watches

196 vzpzt qlcq chi ghd hair straightener ghd hair straightener,jhuls ghd hair straightener qperlr,chi hair straightener,vliwh hair straightener iiqljz,ghd hair straightener,mdigrb chi hair straightener aeixut,chi hair straightener,aoznq hair straightener kinmym,hair straightener,chxem hair straightener aoutozv,ghd hair straightener,tzxzw ghd hair straightener vvxqbk,chi hair straightener,merj hair straightener moyazi,hair straight,hwkgq hair straightener kfeze,ghd hair straightener,fdqgu chi hair straightener ozld,chi hair straightener,ywbmnzj hair straightener auiykx.

197 fxfbz buy cheap wow gold rheb wow gold,brsa buy wow gold onppl,wow power leveling,kidces wow gold dehxm,cheap wow gold,gcbbak buy wow gold smzac,buy wow gold,fuwpe cheap wow gold vqwsy,world of warcraft gold,smuhae buy wow gold mixbi,wow gold,lsoctj wow power leveling dbxvh,wow power leveling,imaq buy wow gold yibst,cheap wow gold,ceenqm wow gold wawsx,buy wow gold,ekcpxn cheap wow gold mvxxx,world of warcraft gold,ieksnk buy wow gold mpnyvw.

198 These various ROLEX Watches ROLEX Watches partnerships have allowed TAG Heuer OMEGA Watches CARTIER Watches to develop a unique watchmaking know how in prestigious watches chronographs with famous timepieces like the Carrera CARTIER Watches Monaco Chronosplit Manhattan 2000 series ROLEX Watches recently the Kirium

199 Watches really Replica Watches are a great fashion replica item. This is because watch manufacturers such as Emporio Armani understand their customers wants and needs and rolex Watches know that rolex watches there is a big market for tag heuer Watches fashion tag heuer watches and designer movado watches in the UK. The number of people that demand these fashion watches has grown enormously over the past few years as people all want to have their own unique personality. Buying a watch can be a breitling watches long breitling Watches process. This is because there are so many watches to choose from that people cartier watches can spend a whole lot of time making their decision. One brand that is always popular is Emporio Armani. This is because Emporio Armani are one of the best fashion brands in the UK and they therefore offer customers some of the best fashion omega Watches available watches on omega the market. There are millions mens Watches of watches for a customer to choose when it comes to a watch. It's quite easy to make the right watch purchase decision. Or you just need to know what famous watch brands are and you may find what you like at once. Emporio Armani watches have been very popular for many mens Watches years.Women's watches Emporio Armani is a brand for style sense and mens Watches fashion which it shows in his range of fashion watches. No matter what watch brand you choose, it can be sure that the watch you are going to wear would show some of your personality.